Tuesday, July 20, 2021

Week 5, Class 9 - “Never mention money”

 Business   Network for life


In the second chapter of Liar’s Poker by Michael Lewis, the author describes how he landed his first job at Saloman Brothers - by doing...seemingly very little. Michael Lewis describes an informal interview process during a Saint James Palace with the Queen Mother hurling his name to the top of the applicant pile. However, after a few more interviews and engagements, he had yet to receive a formal job offer. To which Michael explains, “Salomon Brothers never made job offers. It was too smart to give people the chance to turn it down. Salomon Brothers only gave hints” (25).  Reading this chapter, I thought about our guest speaker Rebecca Fassio and her fundraising comment, “ask for money, and you’ll get one check, ask for advice, and you’ll get two.” 


This subtle approach to building relationships and professional opportunities is a core attribute of a masterful leader. They can turn a seemingly trivial encounter into a chance to build bridges and expand their reach. Rebecca described her calculated and tedious preparation for all social engagements to the extent she captures extensive notes on a spreadsheet. Combining Rebecca’s thoughtful approach with Michael’s subtle yet comprehensive interview process - one might ask, where does authenticity fit into the equation? This level of planning and documenting for every social engagement might transform every conversation into a question of how it can be ‘personally monetized.’ 


I am curious what others think of approaching each social engagement as a potential opportunity and if there are any dangers in losing your authenticity along the way. 


Week5Class2: How much can you control your branding message?

After our guest speaker, Karen Tiber-Leland, spoke last week, I recall asking her about situations where leaders sometimes lose control over their brand or messaging and how this lack of control could consequently impact their quality of decisions, and what her advice would be to limit control over the impact on their brand due to some of their employee’s actions on social media.

Her response, if I remember well, was for us to have policies to educate our staff, but generally accept the fact that you will lose control and can’t do much about it.  

It is important to vigorously maintain the positive aspects of your branding, in the hope that it would counteract any negative fallout from your loss of control over your brand or messaging.  Maintenance may include increasing the frequency of your online posts, presence etc.  This response may also include indirectly addressing the negative messaging that might have to potential to impact your branding.

Pramod..

Ross Johnson - Charismatic Leader or Smoke and Mirrors

 I found the Ross Johnson article deeply interesting.  After reading it a second time, a couple of things popped out that I didn't pick up before.  First, was the quote from the consulting psychologist at the very beginning of the reading:

"Ross’s philosophy is, “We’re going to have a party, a very sophisticated, complicated party.” — * O. C. ADAMS, consulting psychologist to RJR Nabisco"

Had I caught that the first time, I might have been able to predict Ross's style of leadership!  The second thing that popped out was the effect that Tony Peskett had on Ross. Peskett's disdain for authority fueled Ross's insane desire to drive change, whether with or without the support of senior management.   To me, this also planted the seeds for Ross's style of rewarding his loyalists and drinking buddies.   If you were in the inner circle, you could do no wrong though there were a couple mentions of those that fell out of favor.  If you were not in the inner circle, however, regardless of your title of position, you essentially didn't matter. 

Despite all of the banter and boorish behavior, Ross was still able to produce results.  Either he must have had some latent intelligence that gave him insights or he leaned on someone in the organization that was very plugged in.  Even after he retired, he held various board positions at several large companies.

I am sure that if you asked Ross's inner circle about his leadership, he would get rave reviews. I wonder, however, what others outside the closest confidants would say.  In another life, I worked with a customer that had some similar characteristics.  We couldn't talk business, for example, until we had consumed at least two martinis.  He was brash, bullyish and made outrageous demands.  But his employees absolutely loved him and were very loyal.  At the end of the day, he ended up being a very loyal customer of mine.  He didn't beat me up on prices and was very understanding of product or operational issues.  The only condition was that I had to be honest with him about what the problem was and not give him a run of the mill excuse.  

So all that being said, my take on Ross is that he did a lot of things right but was also flawed.  

In class we have learned there are 3 types of leaders:  authoritative, charismatic, and technocratic.  As a parent of 3 children, I can confidently say being authoritative is a lot of work and is not as effective.  For this reason I think authoritative leaders of countries must work really hard and not have much fun.  Further, I think it would be really interesting to research if they are less productive or successful as a country - like I would assume.

Charismatic leaders are likely the opposite extreme and can highly motive people, where people will likely work with little compensation and provide enormous passion.  I assume an initiative under this leadership style would be highly productive and successful.  However as pointed out in class, charismatic leaders can only motive those who work close with them, therefore they are not as effective in a large organization.

Technocratic leaders are recommended in large organizations, however I work for a large organization, and the body of project management knowledge is now saying too many organizations promote authoritative and technocratic leaders, but lack those that can inspire and lead.  Therefore the body of project management recommends hiring charismatic leaders.  I have personally notice that when I am assigned to a project in which I have the technical expertise and exhibit charismatic leadership skills (due to my own passion for the project), my team really excels.  

7/19 - Life as a Brand

 Branding is very crucial to a leader's reputation. A leaders should be careful in their attempts to brand

themselves as that could make or break them in front of others. Celebrities can be a big example of

branding themselves based on their own personal lives. They use their own personal life events to

captivate the audience and gain popularity all across the world. That could be a controversial decision

 for many viewers and critics but no matter what the intentions are the celebrities will eventually gain

followers whether positive or negative which will eventually benefit the celerity at the end. People will

always criticize others and have opinions which can be both beneficial and hurtful to the leader's

image. The Kardashians seem to be not affected by the criticism and considered all the negativity to be

just noise in the background. Kim continued to follow what she planned to do and decided to brand

herself based on her personal life events broadcasted on television. "There is an awful lot of fuss. For 

Kardashian haters, the tipping point came last year

when she filed for divorce from Kris Humphries, a basketball player, after three

months of marriage and a blizzard of wedding coverage said to have been worth

many millions (she will dispute the numbers). The whole thing looked like a stunt to

drum up trade for her TV show, although if it was, it backfired in that for a short

while she was reviled as the most cynical woman in America. She seems to

aggravate male actors in particular. Earlier this year, Jon Hamm unchivalrously

referred to her as a "fing idiot" in Elle magazine, as did Daniel Craig in GQ the

year before. Kardashian takes all this with a certain laconic indifference, the

standard LA response, heightened by what is probably an effort not to emote too

much and generate wrinkles. When I hear people say [what are you famous for?], I want to say, what

 are you talking about, she says slowly, her eyes wide as a bushbaby I have a hit TV show. We've shot

 more episodes than I Love Lucy! We've been on the air longer than. The Andy Griffith Show! I mean,

 these are iconic shows, so it blows my mind when people say that; But you're not performing; you're

 just being followed around by cameras…  ;But to be able to open up your life like that and to be so… if

 everyone could do it, everyone would. It doesn't make sense to me."(The Guardian, Brockes)


The power of a person's image and reputation can define the brand of a person. The Kardashians image

and reputation was so powerful that marketing their products was not a difficult task. They were able to

sell water bottles for $10 just because their pictures are printed on them. The Kardashian name became

a very strong and popular brand because of their popular TV show and many followers on social

media. People were interested in the Kardashians themselves rather than their clothing products which

is evident to their solid brand. The Kardashians did what they had to do in order to strengthen their

brand and increase their popularity. "The day before the interview, I go to Dash in Beverly Hills, the

flagship store aimed at Kardashian's teen fan base. A bouncer stands outside letting teenagers in one by

one, although the store is almost empty. There's a line he calls out to baffled passers-by, and the

teenagers snigger. Inside, the clothes are very nice; soft T-shirts, cute shorts and dresses, but that isn't

why people are here. Kardashian says that's once the show started airing, the store has become a tourist

attraction; and the stock is angled accordingly. After taking photos of themselves in front of a giant

Kardashian family montage, the adolescents buy one of several items within their price-range; a $20

compact mirror; pencils for a few dollars; or a $10 bottle of water with the Kardashian sisters; photo on

one side. Our water sells out all the time; Kardashian says. People collect them because each store has

a different picture on the bottle; That's amazing. It's really crazy she says. I mean, a water bottle? It's

crazy. She blinks slowly at the wonder of effortless profiteering." (The Guardian, Brockes)



2021 07 21 The Technocratic Alternative III

2021 07 21  The Technocratic Alternative III

IRON MAN, RESCUE THIS ORGANIZATION

 Alfred Sloan, My Years with General Motors, Chapters  2, 3

 Sloan says that he is of “two minds” about Mr. Durant. What does he admire about the man and his leadership style?  What does he fault him for? How would he describe Mr. Durant’s  approach to leading GM?  How does it differ from Sloan’s approach? What actions does Sloan take to rescue GM?  How does he reform its management structure? 

It is not clear Sloan is actually of two minds about his colleague and boss,  as he says in one of the early sentences.  Chapter II "Great Opportunities" is uniformly negative on Durant, and reads like a deposition preparation : "He left us with the impression...."  "I had no knowledge.....".  "Involved in any way...."  "Did nothing to aid and abet...."  

Perhaps the first thing Sloan does to help GM is to take notes to report to the future, like Shackleton (who stipulated he had rights to all written diaries), on the great adventure.  Like Shackleton's, Sloan's adventure is available through a telescope.  As for his instincts about management, he seems to have quite a lot of them he is willing to share, if only through the tone of his dismay in relating the events surrounding November 17th-30th, 1920. I'm not sure I believe Sloan on how little he knew of the situation, since he says "many assumed" personal security transactions by executives.  He also mentions the amount of money he had tied up in the company, making his head spin.  This chapter strikes me as a heavily edited 'hindsight is 20/20' dramatization of the good and bad guys.  

Sloan's education had included feckless attachment at a number of tech enterprises before Union Motors.  We learn in the earlier chapter that he had been wishy-washy in his commitment to these since he wasn't sure he liked the companies or people, and felt they ight not really work out for him.  When THE MARKET DEMAND FOR CARS DROPPED IN SEPTEMBER 2020, he explains that at Union/General Motors, he needed to take a month's vacation in Europe to contemplate whether he wanted to stay with that firm.  He was disappointed at his fellow managers' failure to understand the market, and now demand for cars had suddenly dropped!!  Imagine his discouragement, because as a manager, he could never have anticipated demand drop or stock drop, never!  Not as an executive of an affiliate!  So it's a good thing he went to Europe and BOUGHT A ROLLS ROYCE to drive around in, for a think-through vacation on how to address his fellow managers' inadequacies.  

At the end of Chapter II "Great Opportunities" Sloan has conducted a Barbarians at the Gate exercise that may rob owners and managers (while keeping them in the dark), and gets the CEO to sign a release, loan, and initial resignation to save the GM brand (and perhaps the stock Sloan owned) and ensure the company's own "confidence" in the industry (chapter III) going forward.  (He does seem to elide the two events in the story, Durant and certainty of a future for cars). 

My purpose with this critique is not to defend Durant, but to express that however Sloan fluffs up his own greater moral purpose, he is withering in the way toxic know it all coworkers can be: he has something negative and dismissive to say about everyone.  He is the person who stays at the water cooler to report what's really happening in the company to anyone who will listen.

Throughout Chapter II, Sloan is giving us the inside scoop like a fake-earnest "innocent bystander;" he never is connected with any positive action except identifying management weaknesses, personality this-and-that, and the tisk tisk crisis grip that forced Durant into a perfunctory role.  I don't find Sloan's  remarks convincing or edifying.  From the perspective of the 1960s, when this book was published, it is present-ist and a-historical, and Mr. Sloan, I do think you stab people living and dead, in contrast to what Drucker says you said you didn't want to do.  

I have no relation to any of these people and no great enthusiasm for the cars of GM, then or now.

--

"Organization Study" lauded by Sloan, its proud author, does not enter until Chapter III. 

ODE TO A STUDY OF ORGANIZATION

'The special committee delivered its report to the executive committee
and the recommendations [authored by me] were accepted...."

"The report accepted contained a
basic product policy,
a market strategy, and some
first principles,; basically the
purpose of the company

The executive committee had informed the special committee

 that we intended to enter the low price field..."

"His [the competition's] faults....generally go with an aggressive impatient intelligence....

on the other hand, Mr. Dupont was the person we needed...."

"I happen to believe [temperament] 

is more important than [experience with motor vehicle production]".....

"The primary objective of the corporation, therefore, we declared, was to make money,

Not just to make motorcars. Positive statements like this have a flavor

that has gone out of fashion, but I still think the abcs of business 

have merit for reaching policy conclusions....."+

---

+ Quoting, loosely, Mr. Sloan,  My Years at General Motors, Chapter III 


--

Ode to A Technocrat Ahead of His Time


Alfred Sloan

Your customers

Are not

In your picture.



-- 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  1. Sloan says that he is of “two minds” about Mr. Durant. What does he admire about the man and his leadership style?  What does he fault him for?
  2. How would describe Mr. Durant’s approach to leading GM?  How does it differ from Sloan’s approach? 
  3. What actions does Sloan take to rescue GM?  How does he reform its management structure?  How do you think his instincts about management reflect his educational background and his experience in business?
  4. Near the end of the book, Sloan says: “General Motors is not the appropriate organization for purely intuitive executives, but it provides a favorable environment for capable and rational men.  In some organizations, in order to tap the potentialities of a genius, it is necessary to build around him and tailor the organization to his temperament.  General Motors on the whole is not such an organization.”  How does this statement strike you?  Is it a compelling vision of company management?  What kind of leadership style does it suggest?

 Max Weber, Excerpt from ‘Politics as a Vocation

  1. What do you make of Weber’s three “basic legitimations of domination”?  How are they similar?  How are they different?
  2. When Weber discusses charisma, he uses imagery drawn from war and religion.  Why so?  Does this strike you as appropriate?
  3. People say that charismatic leadership has a very personal quality.  What do they mean by this?

 Max Weber, ‘The Nature of Charismatic Authority and its Routinization’ (48-54) in Max Weber on Charisma and Institution Building

  1. How does Weber define charismatic authority?  Why does he suggest that it is often identified with magical powers?
  2. What is the relationship between charismatic leaders and their followers?  How do the latter see their submission to charismatic authority?  What is the quality of the bond between such leaders and their followers?
  3. How strong is the authority of a charismatic leader?  What happens when he stumbles?  Are his followers forgiving?
  4. What is the relationship between charismatic leadership and “bureaucratic authority”?  Between charismatic leadership and “economic considerations?  Between charismatic leadership and “every-day routine structures”?  What do you make of this?

 

Monday, July 19, 2021

Rebecca Fassio and building relationships

I really enjoyed hearing Rebecca Fassio talk about her work at the Harvard College Fund. I wanted to share some fun anecdotes about working within Alumni Affairs at Harvard. My very first job at Harvard was actually as a Staff Assistant and Receptionist for the Harvard Alumni Association (HAA). The HAA seeks to connect alumni with each other, as Rebecca said, which can be through reunion planning, hosting events locally and worldwide, travel, etc. but they also work closely with their Harvard College Fund colleagues. My front-facing role meant I had to be clued into what was going on and be prepared for just about anything. I would say my job had absolutely no role in in traditional fund-raising, but was focused more on alumni engagement. 

The office culture and relationship building that occurs internally within Harvard's development office is truly remarkable. The culture really values relationships over all else. Hand written thank you notes were the norm. People really took the time to stop by your desk to find out who you were as a person, what interests you had, and would follow up on those conversations. These types of genuine interactions are necessary at building trust within an organization and making sure that you can work as a team and rely on others to accomplish a goal. No man/woman can do it alone. You can't run and host an event for hundreds of people as one person. It takes a team working together to make sure everything goes smoothly. What I learned in this job was invaluable in both how I approach my career and even my personal life. 

Although I have MANY great memories, one of my favorites was working with an alum over the phone who was from a 1950s graduating class. They called asking whether they would be the oldest living alum present at the upcoming commencement/annual alumni meeting. If you are the oldest living alumni who attends, you have the honor to lead the Alumni procession and be the first to shake hands with the President of the University. There's a lot of competition for this spot. :) The reality was we really didn't know who the oldest class member that was going to be represented actually was until the day of commencement. If there was foul weather outside, someone might decide not to show up. I spent a great deal of time reassuring the alum that I unfortunately wouldn't know until the day of but that we would keep them informed if we heard any news. Over the course of a few months, however, I really did get to know this alum! I was glad to be able to provide reassurance but also just a listening ear for someone who was so excited about an upcoming day in May.

A few people in the class chat mentioned the fact that people really want to be connected and draw connections to others and places that are meaningful to them. I found that Harvard's alumni network helps strengthen that connection that no matter where life takes you, you can still find your place. 

Week 5, Class 8 - “Is being bad a good thing?”


Love, hate, or nothing at all




In our conversation with Karen Tiber-Leland last week, I was reflecting on her suggestions for personal branding and marketing. In my marketing class last semester we discussed the way companies successfully create polarizing support (or hatred) for their product. Creating “good and bad” parties can be an extremely successful marketing technique as it further emboldens your supporters to defend your brand. A similar analogy would be with politics and the unfortunate polarization we have seen over the past decade. Relating this idea to a leader's personal brand I found myself asking - “is it okay to be the bad guy?” The best branding is typically not in the middle of the road or in a neutral position - typically we like the passionate, strong, or unique identity. The business or leader who tends to be right down the middle is the one who tends to struggle. 


Taking Karen’s advice on branding, do you believe it’s okay to passionately choose a side or persona for your ‘leadership brand’? Or do you believe as a leader you should be agnostic and keep from rocking either side of the boat too much? I find this decision to be an interesting choice for a leader as it seems to be okay if certain people dislike you. If anything, leadership seems to be more about getting a smaller group of passionate followers than a larger group of people who feel indifferent about you. 


So as a leader is it okay to be loved and hated? Or to be a successful leader should you strive to remain neutral and have neither lovers nor haters?


Week5Class1: Leadership & Branding – Complimentary or substitute actions?

In the first few lectures, we learned that a leaders’ claim to leadership must be rooted in some legitimacy.  Further, we learned that a leaders’ claim to leadership must be durable.  And finally, the durability of the claim is rooted in how it is maintained.

Similarly, when a leader brands themselves with specific attributes (charismatic, technocratic, empathetic etc.)., it is important to also know what to do after you declare that branding.  This includes “differentiating what you do and how you operate” (Levitt, 1986).  

Businesses that provide goods and services survive when they have customers to sell their wares.  As in leadership, a business must not only create a customer (as in claim to leadership), but also expend the effort to hold onto the customer for repeat orders (as in maintaining the leadership).

In essence, branding one’s leadership is not an isolated or substitute task, but complementary to your leadership and its associated claims etc.

Pramod..

Ref: Levitt, T., & Levitt, I. M. (1986). Marketing Imagination: New. Simon and Schuster. P. 128.

Flexible Branding

I absolutely loved the conversation we had with Karen Tiber-Leland. Now, I find myself noticing what people are wearing and determining how it impacts my impression! What I found most compelling about her conversation is the requirement for leaders to be on Linked-In and working on their brand. As someone who does not do a lot of social media, I think I was in the same boat as many other skeptical classmates. However, I think this opens up the door to a true leadership mindset that is worth exploring, and that is flexible growth.

Whether they like it or not, leaders are required to adapt to an ever-changing landscape. In my own line of work, I have witnessed many of my veteran co-workers react poorly to change. As I grow in my career, I think I understand why. We spend so much of our career constantly needing to learn and keep up with the demand of business. Then, we fill up all of our free time with other responsibilities, because it helps us to display our leadership prowess. However, we do not give ourselves enough time to look towards the future because we are always struggling to keep up with the present. As leaders, it is important to constantly adapt and learn so that we always stay relevant. In Karen's said, we need to make time for social media and displaying our personal brand for the world to see. I imagine that many leaders have struggled to understand why it is important. However, as Karen's research shows, it is critical in this age to share our brand in the way she presented. It is likely that in another twenty years, the way to share our brand will be completely different than it is today! 

For me personally, I think this flexible branding is what causes leaders to become this 'Jack of All Trades' that we talked about in class. Leaders require diverse skill sets and becoming an expert in one area could make it really challenging to go far. What happens if the area we are an expert in becomes obsolete in five or ten years? Do we wait for the times to change before we go out and seek the opportunity to learn something new? I think having limited knowledge in multiple areas makes it easy to pick new skills up and drop old necessary skills. It gives us flexibility.

Interestingly enough, I have written a lot in my personal journals about being a 'Jack of All Trades' so I appreciated hearing it brought up in class. I looked back on something I wrote on September 17, 2020. "But the question [I ask myself]: why do I seek to be this Jack of All Trades? I think I recognized that the more skills I have leads me to interact with more people. The more people I interact with, the more people I get to learn from." Adding in what I have learned in this class with 2020 Connor, I get to expand my network and share my brand based on the number of skills that I can add to my portfolio.