Hi everybody!
Since I already introduced myself yesterday, and really have not changed a lot since then (despite the excellent class yesterday), I'll tell you about myself by posting this original composition, from my History Proseminar timed test that caused me to miss the Section I meeting and Introduction recommended deadline.
It's a response to a June 14 news article in STAT. We were supposed to assess the normative bias of the article, I think. I ran out of time as you can tell.
Proseminar
22 June 2021
In-Class Writing Exercise: Response to "‘I'm just winging it’: Confusing Alzheimer's drug data cloud doctors' advice" (statnews.com)
Physicians are more harried than ever, being bothered by phone calls, questions, and patients about whom they are registered as 'caring' for. The real tragedy here is that doctors who esteem themselves as scientist and agents of academic discourse are inconvenienced, are surrounded by media yet again, to proclaim from the center of social attention “I’m just winging it.” This is, in accordance with the patently false dismay evinced by the article, a chance for a DeBakey-like spezzatura to come home to the small senior “65 and Up” shop in Pennsylvania as well as the academic scientist.
What makes the topic especially exciting is that everyone loves a new drug, coming as it does with a new clientele and new opportunities for appointments and tests.
It’s not curable, he says. They are seeking a cure. More and more people come wanting to touch the gown of the physician to get a drink of the holy new thing. What can the physician do besides note the backlog of appointments for his or her time, the many complicating cross checks that must be run, and the latest cost of a PET scan.
And still they are calling. While our academic scientist is disgusted at irregular procedure, or the controversy and great publicity caused by this miraculous FDA decision, the small town corporate box physician takes a more glowey eyed tone. Perhaps something will happen, he says. Yes, three persons resigned and all denied the Rx on the panel. They were not ready perhaps, but it happened. Did we mention that the medicine’s name is ADUHELM
Yea, and so many forsake it, and those it might – just might --help. Dr. S, for instance – his mother died.
The disease is so cruel, rendering people old and dead, unlike the rest of life. Something must be done, but is this it? Is this enough?
Maybe something will happen. Surely Medicare will take action on action-ability. When there are so many needy. But first, some lumbar punctures, blood tests, doctor visits, waiting, review visits, and a mandatory PET scan.
Meanwhile, doctors must be inconvenienced. They must be exasperated while getting their names and career highlights set out in articles that also spell the name of the drug – ADUHELM – correctly. And these articles can be written in such a way to give us pathos, longing, pangs of mortality, and belief in something outside ourselves that may be provided under our existing benefits.

Hi Ellen,
ReplyDeleteWhat Seminar is excerpt from?
Pramod..
Sorry Pramod, thought I answered this but it did not save I guess. It's a required methods course for historical study, the basic SS. We talked about whether you can compare wars by counting the number of lost limbs, digits, and orphans rather than just the number of known dead. Would number of countries be a good unit of measurement, etc.
ReplyDelete