Wednesday, June 23, 2021

Thoughts on a Theory of Moral Sentiments

 Hello classmates,

The Theory of Moral Sentiments is not what I would consider an easy read!  But having read excerpts and studied portions of it in economics class, I knew what I was getting into.  As I read through the selections, I found myself thinking about how applicable Smith's sentiments are in today's society.  

For example, many rich and wealthy individuals do a lot of work for charities, which is a good thing.  But then I question the true motive if the fanfare and advertising of the charitable act becomes the center of the whole activity.  Is it the true act of charity that drives the satisfaction or the notoriety that accompanies the act?  Should a true act of charity be performed anonymously?  

Secondly, the Emperor's New Clothes folktale comes to mind in thinking about the statement of  "those that are in power set fashion".   I am certainly guilty of this.  I love to play basketball and though my dream of playing in the NBA has probably passed (though I still hope to get that call one day), I still believe that by buying the newest Kobe Bryant or James Harden shoe, I will somehow be propelled to a 6'6" shooting guard for the Chicago Bulls. This is maybe not the best example as shoes might be literally considered fashion but my point is that in our very social media dominated society, people of notoriety certainly can drive trends in many facets of our lives. 


James

3 comments:

  1. James,

    I enjoyed reading your post.

    Your point about how “people of notoriety certainly can drive trends in many facets of our lives” caught my attention.

    It is a challenge for individuals to suspend judgement of others who are different from us. Their perceived uniqueness sometimes creates this tension within us to want to imbibe symbols of their perceived uniqueness.

    In your example, buying James Harden’s shoes, somehow symbolizes this uniqueness and in the process gives you the joy of owning a piece of Harden’s leadership and celebrity and by extension, makes up for one’s disappointment in not making it to the NBA (as stated in your example).

    Pramod..

    ReplyDelete
  2. I also posted on Adam Smith's theory of moral sentiments. Similar to you, I question if his thoughts are applicable today. As society evolves I think the desire for excess wealth and shame of poorness may fade away. After all, what does one do with excess wealth? How much do they stress do they endure and how health issues do they develop? And those with money may always want more, but the good news is, they can have it!

    People don't have to work for minimum wage or be taken advantage of by large corporations. My step-dad is a multi-millionaire and when I was a kid he told me as long as you do what you love and you are the best at it, you can be a millionaire - even if you are just selling hot dogs! They just need to be amazing hot dogs!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I concur with your step dad's theory - if you love what you do, success will follow!

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.