Saturday, July 24, 2021

2021 07 26 Leadership vs Celebrity

 07 26 2021  Leadership vs Celebrity

My Magic Sunglasses

"Pseudo events spawn other pseudo events in geometric progression.  This is partly because every type of pseudo-event, being planned, tends to become ritualized, with a protocol and rigidity all its own."  *

[And it Takes Leaders to Disrupt Expectations with Non-Conforming Pseudo-Events?]

 It is simply dazzling to consider the calm exhibited by Kim Kardashian when pressed with questions about her identity-as-work.  I'd say immediately that Kim Kardashian is more than a brand -- way more.  She's an elegant performance artist caught -- in 2011 -- being successful.  Not many performance artists can maintain success for very long at all.  What's impressive is the friendly unwelcome to any serious questions of creating product or playing a game.  I'd say her deflections are masterful and this is a brilliant inventor.

The NYT plays an important character role in the article on authenticity.  For instance, it is supposed to be a knee slapper that Michelle Bachmann uses the word authentic.  Har har -- we already know what this article is going to say.  Turns out Hilary Clinton even claimed authenticity, probably the reason she's a multiple time loser in this writer's mind.  We get some grabbing examples and then a bunch of sentences about what "scholars" have always been telling us about multiple selves and authenticity as a holy grail.  Reagan was seen as authentic!  Who knew that this could be such a contemptible quality.  

And yes, of course, it is not to be touted, because that shows a yearning, a wish stated, that is too authentic.  No one can be authentic, so turn the page or go to the Engagements and Weddings section.  Those people featured have received coaching from the NYT weddings editors on the very best in calculated authenticity.  The couples are coached for months and the stories edited.

I read the Boorstin chapters early in the summer.  It's really spot on.  We are fooled into participating in pseudo events and parallel realities because it seems to be a lot of nice people working assiduously to create what no one is willing to acknowledge as a confectionery bubble.  Surely the latest must-see (press conference, sunglasses line launch) is worth that irreplaceable commodity, human attention. No, we don't need the dancers to spread out for the cameras in the shape of the U.S. Flag (Footlight Parade, https://youtu.be/vlV_Qs-b5Z8?t=143 ) because having seen that scene, we are receptive to earnest performance, and spectacular, revelatory, self-stating moment. Extravagant expectations are our reality.  They are the non-reality we reference when speaking of the status quo.**

Show power and star power: does it invariably transmit through inanimate materials?  When wearing my new Sears sunglasses in 2013, I knew there was magic. Later I realized that the very cool shades were branded Kardashian.

  * Daniel Boorstin, The Image, chapter four. 

**The Image, last of intro and beginning of chapter one.

 

---

 

 

 Prompt questions for Ellen's reference below:

Stephanie Rosenbloom, “Authentic?  Get Real,” New York Times, September 11th, 2011 
1. Does the author suggest that any public figure widely admired for her "authenticity" is actually authentic? If not, why not, and what do you make of it?
2.  What does "calculated authenticity" mean?

Daniel Boorstin, The Image, Chapter 1-2
1. How has our definition of what is newsworthy changed over time? How does that change reflect how we see the world around us?
2. How does Boorstin define pseudo-events? Given that definition, what are some of the pseudo-events that you've witnessed or read about in your own lives?
3. What is the relationship between pseudo-events and the appetite for information? What is the difference between them an propaganda?
4. What is the relationship between pseudo-events and the human pseudo-event?
5. How does Boorstin diagnose the relationship between notions of celebrity and heroism?
 
Kim Kardashian Readings
1. How do you understand the relationship between Kim Kardashian and her brand? Can the two be meaningfully distinguished?
2. Is Kim Kardashian authentic? Authentically what (and how has she cultivated it)?
3. What does our fascination with Kim Kardashian say about us? How does she shape those who are her followers? Do you think she's manipulative or even exploitative?
4. Having read these articles, do you like Kim Kardashian more or less than you did before? Do you respect her more or less than you did before?

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.