Monday, July 5, 2021

2021 07 05 - The Power and Limits of Personality

 

 Power and Limits of Personality

 These two readings address asking the question: What is the REASON for your engagement?  They highlight common conflicts between the self and the group, and getting credit for hard work and invention.

Benjamin Franklin, Autobiography

 Q  What do you make of the letters Franklin includes?  Why do the letter writers think Franklin’s work will be important?  What beneficial effect will it have and how will this effect be achieved?

A Franklin predicts that readers will imagine him proud for including letters of approval from higher-ups, but he includes them to support his thesis that his 'religion' is to use resources effectively to better general state of society and possibly the lives of others, and his premise that the method of industry he describes is efficacious.  Also, having forgone day to day vanity and reputational insecurity for tasks such as the subscription library, he considers the success a major part of his legacy, not just the accomplishment but the lesson for others of his success in "believing".    He withstood the naysayers here and there and his goal -- that the common man should be better informed and able to contribute to public discourse -- was achieved as noted by others.  Same with fire volunteer force, scientific publication by a layman, and lighthouses.

Franklin looks back after surprising accomplishment and wants to express that working with others wasn't always easy, but it was always necessary.  Solutions had to be found, differences accepted; sometimes you express what you think is a good idea, and people steal, adopt or scoff at it, and use the occasion to enlarge differences.  Sometimes keeping your head down and persisting in a group-oriented task is enormously rewarding.  Scoffers exist everywhere.  

  Shakespeare, Troilus and Cressida, III iv

In a very confusing play, Achilles is again in crisis.  Ulysses is the Ben Franklin of Greece, staying calm in his argument and emphasizing logical conclusions of small disagreements.  Agamemnon is an arrogant tyrant, the aging star in the tent is a liability.  Given our topic, it's notable that Ulysses has the least personality in the scene.

I'd like to ask others' opinions on how Agamemnon, Ulysses, and Achilles would variously respond to JPR's persistent question in the last two classes:  'Are you willing to have your professional life be totalizing?'  I.e. to have one's life as a 'leader' open for consistent public feedback and review, such that one is obliged to be actively 'brand positive 24/7'?

ULYSSES
Time hath, my lord, a wallet at his back,
Wherein he puts alms for oblivion,
A great-sized monster of ingratitudes:
Those scraps are good deeds past; which are devour'd
As fast as they are made, forgot as soon
As done: perseverance, dear my lord,
Keeps honour bright: to have done is to hang
Quite out of fashion, like a rusty mail
In monumental mockery. Take the instant way;
For honour travels in a strait so narrow,
Where one but goes abreast: keep then the path;
For emulation hath a thousand sons
That one by one pursue: if you give way,
Or hedge aside from the direct forthright,
Like to an enter'd tide, they all rush by
And leave you hindmost;
Or like a gallant horse fall'n in first rank,
Lie there for pavement to the abject rear,
O'er-run and trampled on: then what they do in present,
Though less than yours in past, must o'ertop yours;
For time is like a fashionable host
That slightly shakes his parting guest by the hand,

And with his arms outstretch'd, as he would fly,
Grasps in the comer: welcome ever smiles,
And farewell goes out sighing. 

O, let not
virtue seek
Remuneration for the thing it was;

For beauty, wit,
High birth, vigour of bone, desert in service,
Love, friendship, charity, are subjects all
To envious and calumniating time.

One touch of nature makes the whole world kin,

That all with one consent praise new-born gawds,
Though they are made and moulded of things past,
And give to dust that is a little gilt
More laud than gilt o'er-dusted.
The present eye praises the present object.
Then marvel not, thou great and complete man,
That all the Greeks begin to worship Ajax;
Since things in motion sooner catch the eye
Than what not stirs. The cry went once on thee,
And still it might, and yet it may again,
If thou wouldst not entomb thyself alive
And case thy reputation in thy tent;

Whose glorious deeds, but in these fields of late,
Made emulous missions 'mongst the gods themselves
And drave great Mars to faction.

 Ellen's answers to JPR prompts 

 How does a man come by honor in Achilles’ estimate?  
 
 Achilles thinks honor is a lot of show of respect.  It's external.based on historical things.  

 
Ulysses says, “no man is the lord of anything / Though in and of him there be much consisting, / Till he communicate his parts to others”. 

 Ulysses means 'Hey, Achilles, you are not the only guy on the beach here!  And we can win this war without you, because your future life is through your past deeds added to the learning of others. If you don't share your expertise and talents, you will cease to exist.'


Achilles worries that his great deeds have been forgotten.

Ulysses doesn't address this.  He has already said time is more powerful than great deeds like Achilles's: O, let not/ virtue seek/Remuneration for the thing it was"

 
How does Ulysses describe the competition for honor?  How does he compare the present with the past deed?

You can't quit.  The gods and nature abhor a vacuum.

 --

 

Not discussed but up last/this week:

 Daniel Defoe, The Complete English Tradesman, Chapter VII, "Of the Tradesman in Distress, and Becoming Bankrupt," 42-43.

Marx, "The Power of Money," Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts of 1844

 Shakespeare, Julius Caesar Act 1 Scene 2 

Thorsten Veblen, "Captains of Industry," Chapter IV. Absentee Ownership, The Business Enterprise in Recent Years.

2 comments:

  1. Fantastic insights Ellen! In response to your question, I am not willing to let my professional life be totalizing. I have been in leadership roles of various levels for more than 25 years and have been fairly diligent about keeping certain things private. Very recently (prior to the pandemic), a trend at my company was to have company meetings at manager/leader private residences. I was not in favor of this.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.