Wednesday, July 7, 2021

2021 07 07 Power and Limit of Personality II

 2021 07 07 Power and Limit of Personality II

"Ay, Caesar; but not gone."

Every time I read this play I remember the first time I read it as a backrow freshman in public high school, and how much it affected me because of the incredibly lifelike characters and plausibility in daily affairs.  It's breathtaking to me how realistic it is while being so brief, crowded, and odd.  And why do I feel it was an immediate benefit in handling the stress of high school social life. 

You could write an essay on leadership regarding any one line. Here are some of the chief themes in my opinion in this one scene:

Keeping leadership 

Dealing with special requests

Balancing home and work

Sources of information

What is said vs what is suspected

Beware the quiet observers

Beware vanity in others 

How to be flexible, but not too flexible

Friendship as a holy gift

The transience of power and limits to what one person can accomplish

Those things all come before an analysis of the what happens to the conspirators mentally and literally,which is especially painful in the spat between Brutus and Cassius.  Really moving.

"Read mine first":

This scene sets up an emotional contrast between outside and inside, street and Capitol, and the question of who someone charged with management listens to for the best information.  I love it.  Readers here see that Caesar has thrived by relating to the common man and diverse characters, and in some ways has kept distance from the Cassius types.  Already he has listened to, then not listened to, Calpurnia's concern about a conspiracy.  His instincts tell him this is an important part of his survival.  

Lesson here is this is one person and he is multitasking to the extreme and can't listen to everyone.  His action follows formal duty to attend the special meeting at the Capitol, and he's already acknowledged that anything could happen.

 "Delay not, Caesar. Read it instantly....

CASSIUS. What, urge you your petitions in the street? / Come to the Capitol."

I don't get the test they put him to regarding the banished senator, except that it's a pork=barrel item asked before they kill him.  Or a dramatization of this internal vs external dynamic - the external rules required in social control vs what might, inside the Capital, put Caesar in better position with competitors who are nursing a grudge.  Caesar's unyielding position is in contrast to his willingness to break rules elsewhere "for public order" like crossing the Rubicon, or his previous promise to his wife to avoid the agora.  His speech regarding Cinna's pleas is unconvincing and arrogant

 Be not fond,/To think that Caesar bears such rebel blood/That will be thaw’d from the true quality

With that which melteth fools;

 but I think it is meant to have us ask ourselves how we would have handled this.  Seems like we are supposed to ask 'When are creative rulebreakers and charismatic leaders with masterful technocratic skills not called hypocrites for enforcing the rules?  When does the revolution stop?'

What's interesting is that the two noble frenemies, Caesar and Brutus, both in this encounter (meaning the play) choose principle over progress, or even principle over friendship.  Both say the public good depends on their choosing principle and consistency over going with the flow.  It's particularly tragic for Brutus, who just completely disintegrates, within minutes rationalizing his mentor's death by saying they did him a favor.

Out of time.  Very interested in knowing what you all seize upon in this  passage.

---
 
Addendum 7/31/2021
Smith is very dismissive of Caesar as a leader, and he makes some great points about alternate scenarios along the path of Caesar's victories.I learned Julius Caesar in an era of Post-WWII Cold War exhaltation and empire building.  But Smith's reading of Shakespeare is actually focused on the ghosts that haunt a person of immoderate action toward personal success:

"Of the great and of the learned; amidst the more innocent, though more foolish, acclamations of the common people; amidst all the pride of conquest and the triumph of successful war, he is still secretly pursued by the avenging furies of shame and remorse; and, while glory seems to surround him on all sides, he himself, in his own imagination, sees black and foul infamy fast pursuing him, and every moment ready to overtake him from behind. Even the great Caesar, though he had the magnanimity to dismiss his guards, could not dismiss his suspicions. The remembrance of Pharsalia still haunted and pursued him. When, at the request of the senate, he had the generosity to pardon Marcellus, he told that assembly, that he was not unaware of the designs which were carrying on against his life; but that, as he had lived long enough both for nature and for glory, he was contented to die, and therefore despised all conspiracies. He had, perhaps, lived long enough for nature. But the man who felt himself the object of such deadly resentment, from those whose favour he wished to gain, and whom he still wished to consider as his friends, had certainly lived too long for real glory; or for all the happiness which he could ever hope to enjoy in the love and esteem of his equals" (Theory of Moral Sentiments I.iii.38, p 65 of our print out)

 


 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.