Tuesday, July 27, 2021

2021 07 28 Ambition and Obedience



 Hey Mr. Brooks, These Kids Are, In a Way, Everyday People Too

 

 Blog entry on David Brooks, ‘The Organization Kid,’ Atlantic Monthly, April 2001

Featuring a Q and A with our Blogger, Ellen S.*

 

Blogspot/ JPR: What habits or tendencies characterizes the “Organization Kid”? 

Ellen S. : I think Brooks's submerged point is that this generation is marked by a certain complacency.  They are the product, at Princeton, of scientific parental optimization (of brain synapses, experiential learning, Mozart immersion) and of protective devices unknown before, like seat belts and bike helmets .  It's possible Brooks sees this as different emotionally from the raw physical exposure, and proposed more robust heroic engagement, of Princeton's classes early in the century.  The classes he is writing about have been protected also from strong rhetoric (religious ranting, war talk, calls to moral duty) from any quarter.  One fine example I believe Brooks gives is his quote from the graduation address by prior Princeton president Hibbens to the class of 1913:

You, enlightened, self-sufficient, self-governed, endowed with gifts above your fellows, the world expects you to produce as well as to consume, to add to and not to subtract from its store of good, to build up and not tear down, to ennoble and not degrade. It commands you to take your place and to fight your fight in the name of honor and of chivalry, against the powers of organized evil and of commercialized vice, against the poverty, disease, and death which follow fast in the wake of sin and ignorance, against all the innumerable forces which are working todestroy the image of God in man, and unleash the passions of the beast. There comes to you from many quarters, from many voices, the call of your kind. It is the human cry of spirits in bondage, of souls in despair, of lives debased and doomed. It is the call of man to his brother ... such is your vocation; follow the voice that calls you in the name of God and of man. The time is short, the opportunity is great; therefore, crowd the hours with the best that is in you.

 

This is a dramatic way of contrasting then and now.  Ivy league colleges don't talk that way anymore.  It may be considered uncivil and hateful to talk that way in 2021. 

 

Brooks doesn't want to say that current generations are not as good, but there is the suggestion to be taken away with so much comparing.  Current generations are not fearful of death or tragedy or original sin.  They fear flubbing an interview or missing an opportunity.  My thought reading it was that he was subtly hinting at a machine-like quality about these young people.

Blogspot/ JPR:Brooks tries to draw a contrast between the poetic and prudential frame of mind.  What does he mean by this distinction?  Into which of these categories does the Organization Kid fall?

Ellen S. : This generation is marked by prudence, befitting the seat belts, shin guards, and cell phones used to keep them (as property and livestock) safe.  I don't get his opposition of this with the poetic; it seems a bit stretched to me.  It's ok to wear a toothguard and rage against mortality. 

 
Blogspot/ JPR: How is a person like Hobey Baker different from today’s outstanding students?

Ellen S. : He exposed his body to assault in sport and war, immersing himself in causes that involved others, like team spirit, going downstairs on his hands, and airplane safety checks.  He also died early, which they probably won't.

Blogspot/ JPR: Brooks thinks that students at elite schools today are far less comfortable talking about honor or morality than they were a century ago.  Do you think this is true?  Why?

Ellen S. : I do think this is true.  As we are careful not to say inappropriate things to others, subjects like "doing the right thing," obligation to society, obligation to family, worship, country, the like -- become just too awkward and uncool on anything but a cursory intellectual level. Perhaps it is the safety ethic

Blogspot/ JPR: Brooks’ essay came out before 9/11.  Do you think that, in the years since then, the habits or tendencies of students at elite schools have changed?  How so?

Ellen S. I'm afraid I can't say.  There seems to be a lot of strong opinion on campus, but that could just be the people who are talking to the extended microphones. The strife on campus seems to have taken a Cain vs Abel tone, as groups bicker about relative power here in the material world, and rights seem equated with secular distributions.

My overall response to Brook's article is that he is trying to write a meaningful essay about small changes in daily life and values, small changes in freedoms and priorities, having a significant effect on guiding principles in a generation.  He mentions the absence of trauma and war, which of course applies to the college classes of just before 9/11.  I'm not sure go along with all his assessments, but there is no reason to doubt his sincerity or ability to generate insights upon visiting with students.  --

Blogspot/ JPR: Any additional thoughts on Brooks's thesis in light of your own personal leadership challenges?  

Ellen S.:   Reading the article, I thought of a hand printed poster in a children's shelter / emergency school I saw in 3nd grade when my mom took us to work there after a school field trip (!).  It had a few of these lines:


Sometimes I'm right and I can be wrong
My own beliefs are in my song
The butcher, the banker, the drummer and then

Makes no difference what group I'm in/


I am everyday people/

There is a blue one who can't accept the green one For living with a fat one, trying to be a skinny one And different strokes for different folks
And so on and so on and scooby dooby doo-bee/


Ooh, sha sha
We got to live together/

I am no better and neither are you
We are the same whatever we do
You love me, you hate me, you know me and then
You can't figure out the bag I'm in/

I am everyday people/

There is a long hair that doesn't like the short hair
For being such a rich one, that will not help the poor one
And different strokes for different folks
And so on and so on and scooby dooby doo-bee/

Ooh, sha sha
We got to live together/*

This was not a song in my world at the time, but it made a strong impression, because the lyrics had been copied out by a group (it was probably only about three lines of text) onto a beautifully hand decorated poster board. The point of telling this is that it was like a window for me because it seemed to speak of a ridiculous peacefulness and acceptance of sin and degradation, and the power of hope and culture to provide support.  It was the first time I felt white shame, and I felt it in myself, unprompted by a lesson plan. I'm actually not sure what I took away, but it was a generational moment for me because it seemed hopelessly in the past but yet transfixingly poetic.  

I hope every generation has its own vision of the poetic, and I think it probably does, because each generation is made of adaptive humans.  

 *Sly Stone, Everyday People, Epic Records, November 1, 1968
 https://genius.com/Sly-and-the-family-stone-everyday-people-lyrics

Song may be found here

 https://youtu.be/3JvkaUvB-ec

** This blog is also submitted as a supplement to Ellen S.'s introduction assignment at the first of class because it puts forward a refrain she thinks should be held close by all aspiring leaders.

 

 

 

 ------

 



No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.