Week 4, class 2 - 3 Leadership Hats!
A selection from the Democratic Presidential Candidates Debate in 2008 reveals that Obama is an inspirational leader who motivates others by suggesting we solve national issues together. He is using key motivational techniques that make himself an inspirational public leader. However his speech made me think that there may be other leadership qualities we may not be considering when we assess the full potential skill set of leaders.
Today I gave a presentation at work on project management. I explained that project managers wear 3 hats: a leader, a facilitator, and a technical expert. I further explained depending on the project, a project manager may only wear some of the hats. It is important to self assess and recognize as a project manager if you have the skills to wear all 3 hats or if you need delegate a hat to a team member. For example, a facilitator may be selected to help run meetings and make sure action items are accomplished. Or if technical expertise is need to guide a project, a subject matter expert can be assigned to help the project manager.
Obama had the leadership skills to inspire and motivate people, however I sometimes think he may have lacked the technical skills. And Trump probably had the technical skills, yet may have lacked what Obama had. It is too bad the two could not come together as team like Obama suggested in his speech.
Also, I have been considering our conclusion in the last class that groups elevate a leader who is good at what the group values. I think this is an example of when a leader is promoted due to being a technical expert (3rd hat), but in the case of Obama I think he is considered a leader due to being inspirational (the first hat). And "Agile Project Management" teaches the 1st hat is more important than the other hats, as it is harder to inspire others. I question if this is really true? I think the best leaders wear all 3 hats. It doesn't happen often, but I actually wear all 3 hats on one of my projects at work - and I dominate on this project.
The body of project management also states project managers can lead any type of project or task and be good at it, however I think all 3 hats need to be worn to be an amazing leader of a specific group.
Very insightful post Amber! In a leadership class that I took last semester, one of the models that we discussed was situational leadership which I think is very applicable in a project management scenario. In some situations, the technical aspect is critical. A project management role on an aerospace project, like the space station for example, would require significant technical expertise. Project management for a more cross-functional project, like executing a trade show, might require more of the facilitator role.
ReplyDeleteHi Amber,
ReplyDeleteI think the three hats is an interesting aspect of project management. I do think that having promotional opportunities for both the charismatic (management) levels AS WELL as for the technical job levels is crucial. Having the ability to be promoted and recognized for the technical work you do and specialize in without having to necessarily take on the management responsibilities of an office can make products better. Many companies have two separate tracks, a technical and a non-technical ladder that individuals can work towards which I think is great to match the skills and needs of employees.
This is a very understandable breakdown for those of us who aren't formally trained in logistics or project management. Facilitator is a good word -- why have we not used it before? It's leadership to facilitate.
ReplyDeleteOne difference -- I think Obama had the technical skills and Trump COULD have done this or that (he learned how to use a teleprompter AFTER running for president for a couple months. But I think people follow their inclinations, and when there is stress, they may fall to strengths -- Obama wants to charm and sooth and get everyone less agitated (about Syria or whatever) Trump wanted to find a sharp barb or flashy sound bite. I think these reflexes are pretty natural among people working so hard they can barely think. The hat analogy is good, but can it work in high pressure situations? Maybe THAT is a sign of a super leader. I think many times you see this in a leader only in retrospect.