Over the course of my program at Harvard and in other leadership development programs that I have taken in my career, I find myself with a lasting question:
How can you really measure leadership?
Does achieving certain corporate metrics anoint a leader as successful? If so, what about when a company goes through difficult times and requires strong leadership to survive?
Does affecting change in humanitarian areas warrant success as a leader? How do you measure or quantify the changes? Are the changes long lasting or short lived? How do these variable determine success as a leader?
Does being a brilliant strategist in winning a war or campaign determine a leader as successful?
It seems that there might be a baseline for leadership success but beyond that, it might be a subjective point of view based on the beholder? I might think someone a great leader but any one else could have a completely different perception.
You have a great point here. Leadership is so complex. It appears many leaders are promoted when they possess technical skills that are admired by the people of a particular group. But technical skills aren't enough to be a great leader. They also need to be charismatic. We learned many skills in class to be more charismatic and analyzed different leaders to rate their charisma.
ReplyDeleteCharisma can also be used in negative ways. Liar's Poker made me realize how leaders could motivate good people to essentially make unethical choices. The author explains this is part of the reason he left Solomon Brothers in the end. Perhaps the lesson here is that Solomon Brothers did eventually go bankrupt. Therefore lasting success requires ethical, charismatic and technocratic leadership abilities!
Jim,
ReplyDeleteI have enjoyed reading all your posts in this group that have clearly prompted thoughtful conversation.
In response to your excellent and intriguing question, it appears that the adage “you are only as good as your last mistake” seems to apply to leaders as well. Leaders who do very well to keep their followers or business in order but stumble through a crisis, are more likely not to be remembered well.
Take for example, the Jeffrey Katzenberg & Meg Whitman’s QUIBI startup. When online services of all kinds gained significant traction during the COVID crisis, Quibi, “a streaming-video service designed for mobile phones, featuring “quick bites of content””, shuttered down. As leaders of the startup, Jeff & Meg failed to acquire enough customers to stay solvent. This is despite each of their brilliant track records at DreamWorks and eBay respectively.
So, what KPI do you use in this case – one from the most recent endeavor or a track record that is skewed more toward success or failure with outliers being factored out?
Jim, it was a pleasure being your classmate. Good luck in your future endeavors.
Pramod..
Pramod, I have thoroughly enjoyed working with you over this short summer semester! Your insights, brilliant questions and awesome singing voice will always make me smile!
ReplyDeleteI wish I knew a standard KPI that could be used in measuring leadership. I have often pondered the idea of some type of characteristic measure/indicators but feel like it would end up looking like the Big 5 or similar personality profile.
And to your point about the failed ventures for Jeff and Meg, I think all too often we don't hear about the failures as much as the high profile successes. It seems that there would be more value in the lessons learned from the failures in my humble opinion.
Jim, your question resonates with me. I like what Pramod says too, but I will challenge it with one thought. I feel that even though we are only as good as our last mistake, the people that are true leaders seem to be able to rise to success over and over again too. Even though partially becoming a great leader requires a little bit of luck, but the great leaders do not luck into it.
ReplyDeleteI think that truly great leaders will always find their way to the top.
That being said, it does feel like leadership is trapped in a large amount of paradoxes, which makes it incredibly frustrating to measure.. It's funny to just sit back and realize that regardless of whatever strong opinions we have, someone else out there completely disagrees and has an equally valid opinion too.
You proved that in our breakout session of Kim Kardashian yesterday, when you had a certain opinion that changed by the end of our session.
Fantastic working with you Jim. I feel you had many great stories and insights that really helped light the path for me and my career moving forward!