Sunday, July 25, 2021

Final Question

This class has made me wonder what leadership qualities and approaches are most successful for women and minorities? What differences exist in the perception of the qualities that we discussed in class? We spent a lot of time focusing on the white male perspective and case studies until the very end of the course and inevitably questions did come up throughout the semester in breakout groups about how various leadership styles and situations might be different for others in the same role. 

5 comments:

  1. I am a woman and have been in a leadership role as a Project Manager most my career. I feel that most others respect me as a leader, however I have noticed a few times that men of equivalent ability and age have been promoted quicker and are essentially paid more. Frankly, no one has issues letting me do great work, but the statue and pay is harder to achieve.

    My group presented on Stacey Abrams and she was motivational in that she had all the odds stacked against her, yet became a very strong leader, was promoted to high level positions, and likely had good pay to go with those positions. Perhaps it was harder for her to get there than others, but it is motivational that she did get there. As I gain experience, I realize confidence is everything. If you believe you are worth a certain level of respect, worthy of a position, or demand a certain pay - the world will likely believe it too. So women and minorities need to erase or ignore any prior social programming and simply believe in themselves and know their value!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great question and I agree with Amber's comments from Stacey Abrams. I think what we can learn from Stacey is the idea of 'leading from the outside' or understanding leadership approaches for minorities might have to look a little different. I believe this circles back to the idea of self reflection and social awareness - as a leader you have to be able to read the situation/room and adjust your strategies appropriately.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Juliana,

    Great final post question.

    If I recall, when our guest speaker Mike Issac talked to us early this month, he mentioned that most start-ups are run by men. Despite this fact, the core issue in the perception of a women leader, is about gaining the trust of your followers early in your tenure as a leader.

    Regardless of the inherent societal or cultural biases, if the greater goal of the organization is something all followers (of the leader) can relate to (example Xerox’s ex-CEO Ursala Burns or Theranos’s Elizabeth Homes or Yahoo under Marissa Mayer or eBay under Meg Whitman) then the claim to leadership is easier for women, especially minority women. In Yahoo’s case, all employees seemed to rally around Marissa, ensuring that the company survived when she took over. In Therenos’s case (at least initially) it was being associated with a groundbreaking tech company that helped Elizabeth establish her claim to leadership quickly.

    Juliana, it was a pleasure being your classmate. Good luck in your future endeavors.

    Pramod..

    ReplyDelete
  4. Juliana,

    This a great question. I do not feel fit to provide any answer, but I do hope that you are able to answer for yourself this question.

    While I cannot share a direct answer, I have been grappling with the idea of Leadership being a form of privilege. And your post reminded me of this thought. Being a straight white male, I am very privileged. Even more privileged that I have many leaders that fit my profile. Because of the world view seeing so many leaders as straight white men, it also gives me opportunities that others do not have to step into leadership. Lately, I have wondered if my 'big picture' style thinking that has aided my ascent into leadership evolved from the fact that I had the most privileged upbringing. I did not have to worry about racism or abuse or bullying. I think because of this, I was able to focus on how I could give back to those around me. Since I did not have to worry about myself or my family, I could look to the world and other issues to try to dive into.

    I think most leaders become disconnected from the smaller issues to some extent. Even the biggest leaders with the highest degree of empathy are removed and not facing the issues the exact same way that other people within the same race, gender, or ethnicity might face.

    Thank you for your awesome thoughts and disposition throughout these blog posts. I get the feeling you are a very empathetic leader and you inspire me to dig deeper into myself to give more to those around me.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great question, and kinda shameful that no one else asked it. Agree that Stacey Abrams sets a good example, of not being afraid to say "I want to lead also," and getting skills to do so. The difference she makes, and Hilary Clinton for that matter also, or Sandra Day O'Connor, or Mother Theresa, or even Sonia Sotomayor, Jacinta Arden, or Marie Curie, is being seen just being an average leader. So maybe one piece of advice is to be yourself and don't draw that male/female leadership line in your mind?

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.