Tuesday, July 27, 2021

Liar's Poker

Isaac's post about a**hole leaders really helped me explore the last aspect of leadership that I have been contemplating.  After reading the entire book "Liar's Poker" I was puzzled how a**holes where such strong leaders and a desired employer - because in class we learned that most leaders are only crowned after they demonstrate that they excel in an area that is important to a particular group - by either possessing technical or ethical superiority.  So why did ivy league students desire to work for Solomon Brothers?

Perhaps some ill charismatic leaders can also inspire others to be less ethical or moral?  Gangs are an example of this.  They bring in a vulnerable person, make them feel like they are a part of a family, and they create loyalty to the gang.  Basically gangs or cults follow the steps of being a charismatic leader.  Perhaps Solomon Brothers created this type of culture in their organization.  It was surprising that they could take smart, hard working, and talented people, belittled them, yelled at them, swore at them, hurt their self esteem, made them work 24/7 so they don't have a personal life, fed them junk food, taught them to yell at people to be successful, taught them to be proud when they pawned off the companies bad investments and hurt others greatly - all in the name of making money for the company.  How were these bring Harvard students morally and ethically belittled to this?  If it wasn't ill charisma at it's best, it was lots of money!  

In the end I was pleased that the author let his morals, ethics and values get the best of him and he walked away from the "funny money".  What will stop ill charismatic leaders from spreading their ill to others in the world?  I think laws that prevent large companies from taking advantage of others are important, because it reduces the ability to create funny money and turn takes away an incentive for good employee to become unethical.  Also a societal solution is to educate the students about leadership, ethics and values! 

1 comment:

  1. Hi Amber!
    Stepping back, maybe this world is not more revolting than your average rape and pillage tactic of war. The behavior is so against code, so wildly indulgent, that it creates an upside down world that affects the moral bearings. First by liberating creative juices, then by incriminating participants, so they have a hard time righting themselves or escaping. So it is a very powerful gang "abduction" technique that gets people to sign a contract first and start comparing their position on the greasy corporate slope.
    It just occurred to me that Lewis creates a kind of Dante's hell or tortured souls. The souls are drawn by following the instinct to betterment that gets them play a game that incapacitates the judgement.
    It IS a comedy, or a horror comedy. People go to shops like Salamon because of the status, then the money helps make it worth it, then they need more money to feel the same high. The family back slapping is an overlay and also a support. Power corrupts, and the humor here is all about comparative power, abjection, and manipulation. You might say that's like a family also.....
    Michael Lewis writes an exciting book. Because he has to extol the world and characters to draw us in, in this and other similar books, there's always the sense that he could be exploiting our own greed and competitiveness by getting us wrapped up in it and condoning it while we follow the storyline. But the end result is always that you feel disgusted.
    I've really enjoyed being in this class and blog group with you.
    Ellen

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.