In reading the Marx excerpt, the portrayal of money is that if you have money, people want to be you and people look up to you as a leader, even if you are not actually leading anything. We see this everyday in tabloids and influencers. People follow those who have fancy houses, cars, etc. because they want to be them. The Kardashian family were cited as an example of this for a long time. People used to say that they were famous for being famous. But really, they were a wealthy family even before they were famous. Their father was an infamous lawyer. They used their wealth as a tool to acquire even more wealth and power. Because money can help you buy everything, money is the tool of power.
Money can also buy affection and attention. As Marx puts it, "I am ugly but I can buy for myself the most beautiful of women. Therefore, I am not ugly, for the effect of ugliness -- it's deterrent power -- is nullified by money" (p. 73). Men of power frequently observe that they can use their position to attract the attention of beautiful women. Take a look at any politician who has a stunning partner whose looks exceed their own. Money and power have an attractive quality that can make up for lesser physical attractiveness. Marx supposes that money and therefore power transforms these "real imperfections and chimeras ... into real powers and faculties" (p.74).
Part of the real powers and faculties that Marx is referring to is the ability to pursue your interests. In Marx's opinion, interests don't matter if you can't act on them and if you don't have the funds to chase an interest, then you cannot act on it. There is some level of power in the ability to take this course. You have the money to spend towards your education and so Marx would say that was a genuine interest that you can act on. This is the power that money confers.
Money can put you into the position of power, however, once you're there, you have to maintain a genuine interest. People have to genuinely admire you for you to be a leader. If you are insufferable and uninteresting, people will not follow you even if you have used your money and power to secure the right education, career opportunities, and spouses.
Juliana,
ReplyDeleteMoney can definitely make people powerful by buying whatever they dream of and making others pay attention to them to gain more popularity. But money cannot make a person a better leader because a great leader should be deserved as a true leader. You will not be able to become a leader without skills that could qualify you as one. Money might definitely help but will not replace a person's skills and willingness to be successful.
Interesting point as I have always found the 'weight' of wealth to be fascinating. Money has the ability to offset many shortcomings as an individual, or leader. I wonder why we all have a certain price and if it is right will look past, or accept, defects. I guess because we understand the power/influence that comes with money.
ReplyDeleteHi Juliana,
ReplyDeleteI think this passage by Marx attributes alchemical powers to money, and is too sarcastic. He's right of course, and still right. But this passage is very negative, and what is the logical conclusion of it? If the ugly person (his term) is apportioned an equal amount of money as all others, is he no longer ugly, or just ugly with the same money as everyone else. By naming these other social differentiators, he puts his primary point in question. And suggests money may not be the ONLY THING.
I like this paragraph you write: "Money can put you into the position of power, however, once you're there, you have to maintain a genuine interest. People have to genuinely admire you for you to be a leader. If you are insufferable and uninteresting, people will not follow you even if you have used your money and power to secure the right education, career opportunities, and spouses."
I think the play Julius Caesar richly makes this point, not just about money per se but also political and social power. Julius Caesar was not boring and may not have even changed his stripes, but he was beholden to "public" opinion. The wealth he brought to Rome had been forgotten (according to Antony's speech, and Antony drives that home with the drama about returning the wealth to the citizens in Caesar's will). I like the way the assassination is spun to the people from two viewpoints, both of which they applaud. It's all spin, and then Antony wins when he mentions handouts rather than principle, which makes a mockery of Brutus's position. Thanks for this interesting post on Marx. All best, Ellen