Monday, July 19, 2021

Week 5, Class 8 - “Is being bad a good thing?”


Love, hate, or nothing at all




In our conversation with Karen Tiber-Leland last week, I was reflecting on her suggestions for personal branding and marketing. In my marketing class last semester we discussed the way companies successfully create polarizing support (or hatred) for their product. Creating “good and bad” parties can be an extremely successful marketing technique as it further emboldens your supporters to defend your brand. A similar analogy would be with politics and the unfortunate polarization we have seen over the past decade. Relating this idea to a leader's personal brand I found myself asking - “is it okay to be the bad guy?” The best branding is typically not in the middle of the road or in a neutral position - typically we like the passionate, strong, or unique identity. The business or leader who tends to be right down the middle is the one who tends to struggle. 


Taking Karen’s advice on branding, do you believe it’s okay to passionately choose a side or persona for your ‘leadership brand’? Or do you believe as a leader you should be agnostic and keep from rocking either side of the boat too much? I find this decision to be an interesting choice for a leader as it seems to be okay if certain people dislike you. If anything, leadership seems to be more about getting a smaller group of passionate followers than a larger group of people who feel indifferent about you. 


So as a leader is it okay to be loved and hated? Or to be a successful leader should you strive to remain neutral and have neither lovers nor haters?


5 comments:

  1. Isaac, this is an interesting debate. Part of me thinks that people that don’t rock the boat are closer on the ‘anonymous’ spectrum. As we say in class, if we are the norm, average, etc. can we truly become a leader? It makes me wonder if not rocking the boat is the same as being anonymous.

    ReplyDelete
  2. For some reason, I want to believe that the best leaders are always hated as much as loved. And ironically, that this hate surrounding them can make them go too far (something that comes up in Smith). Am I falling into a "type" trap that all leadership of significance draw partially upon a charismatic presence (even just an idea like guaranteed income) and require for their hearing for others to put aside conventional notions for a moment? The "vision" afforded can inspire positive appreciation but also disgust, and if you are rocking the boat, you will rack up enemies fast. Think of Lincoln. It's intriguing to think what Lincoln would have done in future years -- having gone so far out on a limb with the war against rebel states, and deaths on all sides, would he have chosen "much future moderation"? And of course there were many who hated him for BEING overly moderate. Lincoln is kind of my model for someone who didn't try to fine tune his short-term reputation or respond to the latest complaint of the day.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Isaac,

    It is evident that people will always have love and hate towards a specific person whether he/she does something good or bad. There will always be critics all around us either in business or personally. A leader should look out for what people might think about the decisions made but that should not have a negative effect or become a complete distraction from reaching a specific goal in their leadership.

    ReplyDelete
  4. As we learned in class, technocratic leaders are ideal in large organizations, however without charisma, large organizations may end up with a lot of managers, not leaders. It is important for organizations to look for both technocratic and charismatic leaders in hiring managers.

    Regarding the question: should leaders be loved, hated, or neutral, I think neutral leaders are the managers I discussed above. A leader inspires people and therefore has to stand out, that said it is impossible to please everyone, therefore not everyone will love you.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Isaac,

    Your post prompted me to spin Kantian ethics of “Doing good while being good” on its head and “rebrand” what Kant said to “Do bad while being good”.

    Often times, leaders who need to do things to a company with a focus on keeping the company alive, will likely have to reduce headcount, reduce salaries, sell of divisions etc. These actions may be considered as “bad”, but the leader is doing the company good by taking these “bad” decisions.

    So yes, one can be polarizing but circumstances might dictate the adoption of “Doing bad, while doing good”.

    Pramod..

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.