Sunday, July 11, 2021

Week4Class1: Karl Marx’s “Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844”

I read the Karl Marx’s “Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844” article twice – once as it has been written, and a second time replacing all references to “money” with the words “intrinsic motivation”.

Consider for a moment that Karl Marx’s sensual object is not as tangible as money, but something intangible such as intrinsic motivation.

In his statement “Insofar as man, and hence also his feeling, etc., is human,  the affirmation of the object by another is likewise his own gratification” if we were to argue that the affirmation of the object is actually intrinsic motivation and not money, it would afford a different context to meaningful Leadership.

For leaders, the currency of intrinsic motivation, as a sensual object as in the “common whore, the common procurer of people and nations” is a stronger and longer lasting bond that will “not dissolve and bind all ties”.  A leaders’ intrinsic motivation IS the “universal agent” that binds followers with their leader and not of “separation” as Karl Marx argues using the word “money”.

A leader’s ability to intrinsically motivate their followers “is truly creative power”, for motivating followers with money merely lasts as long as the ability of that money to stand the onslaught of ones’ material desires.

Pramod..

6 comments:

  1. Pramod,

    I find your piece about the "leader's ability to intrinsically motivate their followers is truly creative power" very interesting. I agree with you, but I am curious how you believe a leader can help increase, or decrease, the amount of intrinsic motivation in their followers. For me, I believe it's purpose - if a leader can effectively make their followers feel connected to a bigger purpose they will be intrinsically motivated.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Isaac,

      Thank you for your response.

      I agree with you. An important driver of intrinsic motivation is having a “higher” purpose, without which one is relegated to the whims of lower level needs (as in survival etc.)

      Pramod..

      Delete
  2. Now I am thinking back to the article and trying to place intrinsic motivation in all of it. Did you find anywhere that it might not exactly fit in the passage?

    I think that this concept would be similar to the ‘American Dream’. In the US especially, we strongly believe that given enough motivation and determination, people can achieve success.

    I personally struggle with these concepts. On one hand my father very much lived the American Dream, and because of his success I was far more privileged than he was. I saw the outcome of his own success and now seek it for myself as well.

    However, I do also see so many people passed over because they do not have the money to get certain opportunities. During the reading for me, I did see points where money was the ability to fast track or offset certain things. I think most of us would never be so wealthy that we’d be able to accomplish everything with money. That being said, I think a good leader could also be one that recognizes his or her shortcomings, and then leverages money (ex. Hiring a staff of experts) to offset their own shortcomings.

    Fascinating thoughts!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Connor,

    Thank you for your response.

    I agree with your comment about the importance of money. The ability or willingness to reach the level of being intrinsically motivated, inadvertently goes through the tried and tested path of seeking money.

    As long as we have material needs, there appears no direct path to intrinsic motivation.

    Pramod..

    ReplyDelete
  4. I know a number of years ago there was that study that workers would be most happy reaching a salary of $75,000/year and beyond that, happiness and productivity would not necessarily increase. I'm sure nowadays that number is probably closer to $100,000/year. I think that if you consider Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs, people need to satisfy their basic needs first before they can focus on higher level needs. People need to be able to afford housing, food, clothing, clean air, water, childcare, employment and healthcare before they actually can focus on other needs. I feel that intrinsic motivation would only kick in once you've met these most basic needs. Before that, the intrinsic motivation is to survive, rather than produce for your employer/leader.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Juliana,

    Thank you for your response.

    Satisfying basic needs and pursuing intrinsic motivation need not follow one another. You can be intrinsically motivated while you are satisfying the basic needs you have listed.

    Pramod..

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.