Sunday, July 25, 2021

Boorstin

 The reading on Boorstin really struck me in the discussion of hero and celebrity.  I am not sure I completely agree with Boorstin in that heroes transition into celebrity and then ultimately fade away.  The Lindbergh case certainly illustrates this point of view but I believe that time and the era are relevant variables in the discussion.

In some instances, a leader may not be considered a hero in his own time.  But as time passes and history places a different light on the circumstances, decisions, etc., the hero moniker may be applied. Several past presidents come to mind in this instance.  To me, this conflicts with Boorstin's take on the hero transition.  Perhaps another way to look at the time effect is where a leader may be lauded as a corporate hero but later down the line, it is found that the results obtained were a facade.  Numerous examples come to mind here from the corporate world. Do these "heroes" fade away or do they remain in history to be emulated, imitated, studied and analyzed?

Take our own class, for example, we have looked at numerous leaders that are well beyond their contemporary time frame.  Did they fade into obscurity or become victims of "here today, gone tomorrow" celebrity? Obviously not! 

I can't help but think of Warhol's famous "15 minutes of fame" quote which, in my opinion, is especially applicable in today's social media driven environment.  In this light, I agree with Boorstin's characterization of celebrity.  Whether good or bad public presence, some public presence is better than no publice presence and many fight to continue to stay relevant in the public eye.

I contend, however, that true and genuine heroes remain in the public eye without the need for manufactured reasons to be remembered. 



2 comments:

  1. Hi James! Question: do all heroes need to be in the public eye? Do all leaders need to be in the public eye? And also, if they are in the public eye, must they stay there to remain "being and becoming" leaders anew? I remember reading long after it's inception of George W Bush's campaign to paint portraits of veterans of the Gulf War. I thought it was so nice that the news was coming out long after the work. Jimmy Carter also has done so many unpublicized things for good (despite all the books!)

    We really never defined what this class means by leader. In the presentations we've had at least one person who was followed, through her great skill, into a fraudulent or grossly mistaken, business plan. We've had one person talk people into visiting an uninhabitable continent, then taking credit for getting them out alive (if not undamaged). No question these people were types of leaders. You can also have people like the Italian fencer who may have drugged a teammate so he could get the competing slot at the Olympics. He was arguably the best in the world thereafter (from 2008) and is revered by Italian children, so is it excusable in the name of leadership of the many, if he pays it back to society in some way?

    I would like to congratulate the person of, the coaches of, and the family of, and all those who have been defeated by (the hundreds of thousands) --- LEE KIEFER. I met her when she was a newborn. Like a machine, she ran a career that was flawless, and she is married to someone I've known since 2002. Lee is the kind of person you can't believe can be perfect in every way, and power their way to the top. I saw it happen. It's awesome, in a good way, but knowing how many wonderful hardworking young women across the globe wanted that gold medal (having met them in some occasions) it's also fearsome. There is a lot of leadership in setting that example, and if Gerek Meinhardt wins the gold tomorrow, there is no way they can disappear from the public eye. But what a road! Sometimes mediocrity can be a blessing (speaking for myself).

    Sorry so long. Just heard that the matches were yesterday and Lee won gold.

    ReplyDelete
  2. On that topic, want to acknowledge Amgad Khazbak, her coach, who somehow is loved by everyone. In a highly competitive sport world, that's not easy. Also fellow U.S. Muslim American Maura Hamza, who endured a lot of heat by coaching his own very young son, who finished highest among the U.S. men in foil. JPR, especially Amgad Khazbak would be an excellent subject for any leadership study.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.