Tuesday, July 27, 2021

2021 07 28 Ambition and Obedience



 Hey Mr. Brooks, These Kids Are, In a Way, Everyday People Too

 

 Blog entry on David Brooks, ‘The Organization Kid,’ Atlantic Monthly, April 2001

Featuring a Q and A with our Blogger, Ellen S.*

 

Blogspot/ JPR: What habits or tendencies characterizes the “Organization Kid”? 

Ellen S. : I think Brooks's submerged point is that this generation is marked by a certain complacency.  They are the product, at Princeton, of scientific parental optimization (of brain synapses, experiential learning, Mozart immersion) and of protective devices unknown before, like seat belts and bike helmets .  It's possible Brooks sees this as different emotionally from the raw physical exposure, and proposed more robust heroic engagement, of Princeton's classes early in the century.  The classes he is writing about have been protected also from strong rhetoric (religious ranting, war talk, calls to moral duty) from any quarter.  One fine example I believe Brooks gives is his quote from the graduation address by prior Princeton president Hibbens to the class of 1913:

You, enlightened, self-sufficient, self-governed, endowed with gifts above your fellows, the world expects you to produce as well as to consume, to add to and not to subtract from its store of good, to build up and not tear down, to ennoble and not degrade. It commands you to take your place and to fight your fight in the name of honor and of chivalry, against the powers of organized evil and of commercialized vice, against the poverty, disease, and death which follow fast in the wake of sin and ignorance, against all the innumerable forces which are working todestroy the image of God in man, and unleash the passions of the beast. There comes to you from many quarters, from many voices, the call of your kind. It is the human cry of spirits in bondage, of souls in despair, of lives debased and doomed. It is the call of man to his brother ... such is your vocation; follow the voice that calls you in the name of God and of man. The time is short, the opportunity is great; therefore, crowd the hours with the best that is in you.

 

This is a dramatic way of contrasting then and now.  Ivy league colleges don't talk that way anymore.  It may be considered uncivil and hateful to talk that way in 2021. 

 

Brooks doesn't want to say that current generations are not as good, but there is the suggestion to be taken away with so much comparing.  Current generations are not fearful of death or tragedy or original sin.  They fear flubbing an interview or missing an opportunity.  My thought reading it was that he was subtly hinting at a machine-like quality about these young people.

Blogspot/ JPR:Brooks tries to draw a contrast between the poetic and prudential frame of mind.  What does he mean by this distinction?  Into which of these categories does the Organization Kid fall?

Ellen S. : This generation is marked by prudence, befitting the seat belts, shin guards, and cell phones used to keep them (as property and livestock) safe.  I don't get his opposition of this with the poetic; it seems a bit stretched to me.  It's ok to wear a toothguard and rage against mortality. 

 
Blogspot/ JPR: How is a person like Hobey Baker different from today’s outstanding students?

Ellen S. : He exposed his body to assault in sport and war, immersing himself in causes that involved others, like team spirit, going downstairs on his hands, and airplane safety checks.  He also died early, which they probably won't.

Blogspot/ JPR: Brooks thinks that students at elite schools today are far less comfortable talking about honor or morality than they were a century ago.  Do you think this is true?  Why?

Ellen S. : I do think this is true.  As we are careful not to say inappropriate things to others, subjects like "doing the right thing," obligation to society, obligation to family, worship, country, the like -- become just too awkward and uncool on anything but a cursory intellectual level. Perhaps it is the safety ethic

Blogspot/ JPR: Brooks’ essay came out before 9/11.  Do you think that, in the years since then, the habits or tendencies of students at elite schools have changed?  How so?

Ellen S. I'm afraid I can't say.  There seems to be a lot of strong opinion on campus, but that could just be the people who are talking to the extended microphones. The strife on campus seems to have taken a Cain vs Abel tone, as groups bicker about relative power here in the material world, and rights seem equated with secular distributions.

My overall response to Brook's article is that he is trying to write a meaningful essay about small changes in daily life and values, small changes in freedoms and priorities, having a significant effect on guiding principles in a generation.  He mentions the absence of trauma and war, which of course applies to the college classes of just before 9/11.  I'm not sure go along with all his assessments, but there is no reason to doubt his sincerity or ability to generate insights upon visiting with students.  --

Blogspot/ JPR: Any additional thoughts on Brooks's thesis in light of your own personal leadership challenges?  

Ellen S.:   Reading the article, I thought of a hand printed poster in a children's shelter / emergency school I saw in 3nd grade when my mom took us to work there after a school field trip (!).  It had a few of these lines:


Sometimes I'm right and I can be wrong
My own beliefs are in my song
The butcher, the banker, the drummer and then

Makes no difference what group I'm in/


I am everyday people/

There is a blue one who can't accept the green one For living with a fat one, trying to be a skinny one And different strokes for different folks
And so on and so on and scooby dooby doo-bee/


Ooh, sha sha
We got to live together/

I am no better and neither are you
We are the same whatever we do
You love me, you hate me, you know me and then
You can't figure out the bag I'm in/

I am everyday people/

There is a long hair that doesn't like the short hair
For being such a rich one, that will not help the poor one
And different strokes for different folks
And so on and so on and scooby dooby doo-bee/

Ooh, sha sha
We got to live together/*

This was not a song in my world at the time, but it made a strong impression, because the lyrics had been copied out by a group (it was probably only about three lines of text) onto a beautifully hand decorated poster board. The point of telling this is that it was like a window for me because it seemed to speak of a ridiculous peacefulness and acceptance of sin and degradation, and the power of hope and culture to provide support.  It was the first time I felt white shame, and I felt it in myself, unprompted by a lesson plan. I'm actually not sure what I took away, but it was a generational moment for me because it seemed hopelessly in the past but yet transfixingly poetic.  

I hope every generation has its own vision of the poetic, and I think it probably does, because each generation is made of adaptive humans.  

 *Sly Stone, Everyday People, Epic Records, November 1, 1968
 https://genius.com/Sly-and-the-family-stone-everyday-people-lyrics

Song may be found here

 https://youtu.be/3JvkaUvB-ec

** This blog is also submitted as a supplement to Ellen S.'s introduction assignment at the first of class because it puts forward a refrain she thinks should be held close by all aspiring leaders.

 

 

 

 ------

 



The Final Question

Does stepping into leadership require us to sacrifice the perception of who we are to our followers? If so, how does one achieve this?

This feels like an interesting paradox for my specific journey, but let me give you a little bit more background so we can be on the same page. I believe that the human experience is about growth. It is the one constant that is there throughout our entire lives. At least, when I hear the question, "Why are we here?", growth is my response. I like to grow, and I like to see others grow and develop as well. Part of attaining growth, and knowledge as a byproduct, is to share it with others and hopefully impact their lives for the better. This is my intrinsic motivation. I am taking this class because I am fueled by growing people/businesses/technology -- or maybe I should call it innovation. To me, innovation is just a fancy way of saying 'growth'. How can we grow or improve businesses to be better? I find myself here and now contemplating the mysteries of leadership because of the pursuit of a graduate certificate in Innovation and Entrepreneurship.

So, from these interests, I find that I am motivated to use innovation to better the lives of those around me. I am recognizing that I used to find this goal easier. Why? Well, when I started out my journey, I started from nothing. I was working with six people and I could directly see the impact that I was having on their lives with the innovation I brought to the team. As my leadership grew, I expanded to ten and then fifteen. However, it was still easy to maintain. I learned very early that communication is the most important tool for leadership. Directly talking with people and hearing their troubles and them hearing my ideas and seeing what I am planning worked out the best. Now, It feels like every day I have more people that rely on me. At least in terms of my job role's responsibilities, I am responsible for supporting a team of close to 70 engineers. However, because I expand past my role and find new people that can benefit from what I know, I work pretty frequently with another 50. And then outside of that, I am a subject matter expert for a particular software in my company and could expect to support any of our 600 local employees and about 20 global team members at a moments notice

The obvious answer is that I cannot do things the same way I once did. Communication is way different and far more challenging. I do not see the direct impact of my labor, nor do the people I once supported so intimately see that I am even doing anything to continue making their job easier. From their perspective, I am too far removed from their work and not doing anything. This couldn't be further from the truth, but I recognize that my general manager could say the same thing. He is also supporting the whole business and working towards growing our business. So why does it feel different to me? Why do I care so much about the people at the bottom and if they know that I put my energy into what I do for them? I find myself questioning why does it even matter if they do know this? Is this just my ego seeking praise for what I am doing? Or was my initial goal to help these people, regardless of if I get the praise for my work. 

I continue to convince myself that the latter is most important for me. At the end of the day, I am okay with the sacrifice of being popular if it means that I know I am doing good work for them. However, is this a good leadership move? If these are the people that crown me, shouldn't I be trying to focus my attention on maintaining my leadership with them? 

The other element is that as I continue to do more work and climb the corporate ladder, I am now more visible to my bosses and my upper management. Is it now they who crown me? Technically, I do get more opportunities to expand my reach by appealing to senior management. So shouldn't I be using the limited time I have for communication in an effort to appeal to my bosses? Ultimately, their support will be what allows me to impact more people.

These days, I recognize that the perception of who I am to the people that I was originally motivated to help has waned. It is a bit of a crisis of sorts because the core of who I was is now challenged. I suppose to some extent this proves that I am still growing, however, it is a hard thing to give up. Is this something that all leaders have to give up? How do the POTUS or celebrities truly deal with all of the negative comments? It is not possible to go and have a conversation with every person that thinks differently or has preconceived notions to convince them of my way of thinking. So do I just give up? How can I reframe my mind to allow me to do this? 

Another way to look at it is that leadership tends to be big picture vs. small picture in this scenario. A leader sees the high-level vision and strives for that goal. However, the everyday person sees a smaller picture. They see what is happening in their lives and the struggles they face. They do not care about what could happen in a few years. Their problems exist now. How should a leader balance this? Should they attempt to spend their time getting people on board with their vision? How do they address the small picture but make sure that adequate time is spent chasing those bigger-picture improvements/ goals?

I do apologize for the lengthy post, but I really wanted to go all-in on this question! I want to say that it has been a genuine pleasure sharing a blog page with you all. I have enjoyed reading your thoughts and co-creating this experience with all of you. Next semester will likely be my last two classes at HES for a while, so I hope that I will see you in one of them! If not, keep moving ahead. You all are amazing leaders and I hope that you continue to learn and grow so that you can impact those around you in the same way you did for me!





Liar's Poker

Isaac's post about a**hole leaders really helped me explore the last aspect of leadership that I have been contemplating.  After reading the entire book "Liar's Poker" I was puzzled how a**holes where such strong leaders and a desired employer - because in class we learned that most leaders are only crowned after they demonstrate that they excel in an area that is important to a particular group - by either possessing technical or ethical superiority.  So why did ivy league students desire to work for Solomon Brothers?

Perhaps some ill charismatic leaders can also inspire others to be less ethical or moral?  Gangs are an example of this.  They bring in a vulnerable person, make them feel like they are a part of a family, and they create loyalty to the gang.  Basically gangs or cults follow the steps of being a charismatic leader.  Perhaps Solomon Brothers created this type of culture in their organization.  It was surprising that they could take smart, hard working, and talented people, belittled them, yelled at them, swore at them, hurt their self esteem, made them work 24/7 so they don't have a personal life, fed them junk food, taught them to yell at people to be successful, taught them to be proud when they pawned off the companies bad investments and hurt others greatly - all in the name of making money for the company.  How were these bring Harvard students morally and ethically belittled to this?  If it wasn't ill charisma at it's best, it was lots of money!  

In the end I was pleased that the author let his morals, ethics and values get the best of him and he walked away from the "funny money".  What will stop ill charismatic leaders from spreading their ill to others in the world?  I think laws that prevent large companies from taking advantage of others are important, because it reduces the ability to create funny money and turn takes away an incentive for good employee to become unethical.  Also a societal solution is to educate the students about leadership, ethics and values! 

Final Question - Which leadership style is more effective?

 Technocratic vs Charismatic

Which leadership style is more effective in defining a better leader. Leaders tend to have different styles of

 leadership which can determine whether they are good or bad leaders. Technocratic leaders rely on their

 own technical expertise and follow specific rules and regulations to run a bureaucracy or organization. On

 the other hand, charismatic leaders rely on their personal qualities and skills to motivate and inspire

 others to succeed. Can leaders have both qualities to succeed or do they need to choose a specific style

 that might contribute to their success the most? Which leadership style is more successful? How can you

 determine the authenticity of a leader?

Monday, July 26, 2021

Week 6, Class 10 - "Do you need to be an a**hole?"

 7-26-2021


Week 6, Class 10 - Final Question 


“Do you have to be an a**hole to be an effective leader?”



This question is one I have asked myself since starting the Management program, and as I complete my second to the last course I believe I have an answer. Throughout our course, I’ve learned the power of authenticity, empathy, presentation, and self-reflection. Asking myself this question again, I believe you can be an effective leader by being an a**hole. However, the new follow-up question I have after taking this course is “but are you an efficient leader?” Ruling in a fully authoritarian, or tyrannical manner can most definitely lead to results - but the journey to get those results is often a less efficient one. Imagining the analogy of pushing a boulder up a hill or tapping it down the hill, we can imagine the a**hole leader is the former. By taking a more authoritarian approach a leader tends to silence those voices who would otherwise help them be more efficient. Part of the role of a great and efficient leader is the ability to build a network of support. This network is vital in distributing the workload, and burden, of leadership. Without a strong and diverse network who is willing to work for you, a leader will soon find themselves out of time and out of help. 


While appropriate leadership types definitely differ by industry or context, I believe the goal isn’t to just be an effective leader - rather an effective AND efficient leader. To do this you must lead with empathy, transparency, by example, and through creating allies wherever you go. So if you are in a leadership position and it currently seems like you are pushing the rock up the hill, stop and ask yourself: 

  • Am I being efficient with my leadership? 

  • How can I get my network to work with me, and not against me? 

  • What does efficiency look like in my leadership role? 

Complexities of Leadership!

This class has taught us how complicated gaining and maintaining leadership is.  Some are born into leadership and have to minimize risk to maintain it.  Others have to gain leadership status by earning it.  And some do whatever it takes to get authoritative positions like a dictator.  

I feel that countries or organizations led by authoritative leaders are less motivational, inspirational, and successful, therefore earned leadership (and a government system that promotes such) is beneficial.  Within the earned leadership category, there are charismatic and technocratic leaders.  Charismatic leaders are great at being seen as a leader in a short period of time and gaining lots of followers, therefore they are rather successful in politics.  Technocratic leaders are more successful in large organizations where structure and processes become rather important.  

However possessing both skills actually make politicians and managers in large organizations more successful.  Further, the body of project management, has noticed this as well.   Therefore large organization are now encouraged to promote people who also have charismatics leadership skills because organizations are far more successful when managers motivate staff, let them be creative, and let staff take ownership over their work!

Sunday, July 25, 2021

Final Question

This class has made me wonder what leadership qualities and approaches are most successful for women and minorities? What differences exist in the perception of the qualities that we discussed in class? We spent a lot of time focusing on the white male perspective and case studies until the very end of the course and inevitably questions did come up throughout the semester in breakout groups about how various leadership styles and situations might be different for others in the same role. 

2021 07 28 Final Question

 07 26 2021  Leadership vs Celebrity

My Magic Sunglasses

"Pseudo events spawn other pseudo events in geometric progression.  This is partly because every type of pseudo-event, being planned, tends to become ritualized, with a protocol and rigidity all its own."  *

[And it Takes Leaders to Disrupt Expectations with Non-Conforming Pseudo-Events?]

 It is simply dazzling to consider the calm exhibited by Kim Kardashian when pressed with questions about her identity-as-work.  I'd say immediately that Kim Kardashian is more than a brand -- way more.  She's an elegant performance artist caught -- in 2011 -- being successful.  Not many performance artists can maintain success for very long at all.  What's impressive is the friendly unwelcome to any serious questions of creating product or playing a game.  I'd say her deflections are masterful and this is a brilliant inventor.

The NYT plays an important character role in the article on authenticity.  For instance, it is supposed to be a knee slapper that Michelle Bachmann uses the word authentic.  Har har -- we already know what this article is going to say.  Turns out Hilary Clinton even claimed authenticity, probably the reason she's a multiple time loser in this writer's mind.  We get some grabbing examples and then a bunch of sentences about what "scholars" have always been telling us about multiple selves and authenticity as a holy grail.  Reagan was seen as authentic!  Who knew that this could be such a contemptible quality.  

And yes, of course, it is not to be touted, because that shows a yearning, a wish stated, that is too authentic.  No one can be authentic, so turn the page or go to the Engagements and Weddings section.  Those people featured have received coaching from the NYT weddings editors on the very best in calculated authenticity.  The couples are coached for months and the stories edited.

I read the Boorstin chapters early in the summer.  It's really spot on.  We are fooled into participating in pseudo events and parallel realities because it seems to be a lot of nice people working assiduously to create what no one is willing to acknowledge as a confectionery bubble.  Surely the latest must-see (press conference, sunglasses line launch) is worth that irreplaceable commodity, human attention. No, we don't need the dancers to spread out for the cameras in the shape of the U.S. Flag (Footlight Parade, https://youtu.be/vlV_Qs-b5Z8?t=143 ) because having seen that scene, we are receptive to earnest performance, and spectacular, revelatory, self-stating moment. Extravagant expectations are our reality.  They are the non-reality we reference when speaking of the status quo.**

Show power and star power: does it invariably transmit through inanimate materials?  When wearing my new Sears sunglasses in 2013, I knew there was magic. Later I realized that the very cool shades were branded Kardashian.

  * Daniel Boorstin, The Image, chapter four. 

**The Image, last of intro and beginning of chapter one.

 

---

 

 

 Prompt questions for Ellen's reference below:

Stephanie Rosenbloom, “Authentic?  Get Real,” New York Times, September 11th, 2011 
1. Does the author suggest that any public figure widely admired for her "authenticity" is actually authentic? If not, why not, and what do you make of it?
2.  What does "calculated authenticity" mean?

Daniel Boorstin, The Image, Chapter 1-2
1. How has our definition of what is newsworthy changed over time? How does that change reflect how we see the world around us?
2. How does Boorstin define pseudo-events? Given that definition, what are some of the pseudo-events that you've witnessed or read about in your own lives?
3. What is the relationship between pseudo-events and the appetite for information? What is the difference between them an propaganda?
4. What is the relationship between pseudo-events and the human pseudo-event?
5. How does Boorstin diagnose the relationship between notions of celebrity and heroism?
 
Kim Kardashian Readings
1. How do you understand the relationship between Kim Kardashian and her brand? Can the two be meaningfully distinguished?
2. Is Kim Kardashian authentic? Authentically what (and how has she cultivated it)?
3. What does our fascination with Kim Kardashian say about us? How does she shape those who are her followers? Do you think she's manipulative or even exploitative?
4. Having read these articles, do you like Kim Kardashian more or less than you did before? Do you respect her more or less than you did before?

Final Question

 Over the course of my program at Harvard and in other leadership development programs that I have taken in my career, I find myself with a lasting question:  

How can you really measure leadership?

Does achieving certain corporate metrics anoint a leader as successful?  If so, what about when a company goes through difficult times and requires strong leadership to survive?

Does affecting change in humanitarian areas warrant success as a leader?  How do you measure or quantify the changes?  Are the changes long lasting or short lived?  How do these variable determine success as a leader? 

Does being a brilliant strategist in winning a war or campaign determine a leader as successful? 

It seems that there might be a baseline for leadership success but beyond that, it might be a subjective point of view based on the beholder? I might think someone a great leader but any one else could have a completely different perception. 

Boorstin

 The reading on Boorstin really struck me in the discussion of hero and celebrity.  I am not sure I completely agree with Boorstin in that heroes transition into celebrity and then ultimately fade away.  The Lindbergh case certainly illustrates this point of view but I believe that time and the era are relevant variables in the discussion.

In some instances, a leader may not be considered a hero in his own time.  But as time passes and history places a different light on the circumstances, decisions, etc., the hero moniker may be applied. Several past presidents come to mind in this instance.  To me, this conflicts with Boorstin's take on the hero transition.  Perhaps another way to look at the time effect is where a leader may be lauded as a corporate hero but later down the line, it is found that the results obtained were a facade.  Numerous examples come to mind here from the corporate world. Do these "heroes" fade away or do they remain in history to be emulated, imitated, studied and analyzed?

Take our own class, for example, we have looked at numerous leaders that are well beyond their contemporary time frame.  Did they fade into obscurity or become victims of "here today, gone tomorrow" celebrity? Obviously not! 

I can't help but think of Warhol's famous "15 minutes of fame" quote which, in my opinion, is especially applicable in today's social media driven environment.  In this light, I agree with Boorstin's characterization of celebrity.  Whether good or bad public presence, some public presence is better than no publice presence and many fight to continue to stay relevant in the public eye.

I contend, however, that true and genuine heroes remain in the public eye without the need for manufactured reasons to be remembered. 



Final Post Question

Although we have learned about Leadership claims, maintenance and durability, a question that remains in my mind about leadership is about that one ingredient that is required to weather the constant barrage of unknowns that tests a leaders desire to continue functioning as a leader.

What is that one ingredient that will keep a leader focused despite running out of money?

What is that one ingredient that will keep a leader focused despite facing personal adversities?

What is that one ingredient that will keep a leader focused despite losing his followers?

What is that one ingredient that will keep the “leadership fire” burning despite constant failures?

Pramod..

Saturday, July 24, 2021

The Organization Kid Reflection

Reading through this 2001 article, there are a number of points that I find really interesting and some may be not so relevant today. In describing America's elite at Princeton University, Brooks peels back the onion and makes the reader question what is it that colleges and universities should provide students? What is an education, exactly? A means to an end towards a great well paying job... or a way to find yourself and your true character?

The difference really can come down to socioeconomic status and luck. Are you part of the elite who has been groomed to succeed, traveled to foreign places to be 'culturally enlightened', and lucky enough to make it into an Ivy League? Or did you grow up economically disadvantaged, work through high school and college to pay your way, and manage to be moderately successful while juggling real life struggles? These two experiences are very different. 

I'm intrigued by the way Brooks describes the elite as not wanting to question authority. At first, I thought the same. Why would this generation going to Princeton, having all the advantages not raise questions? What do they have to lose? It's certainly not the same risk as someone in a more disadvantaged position. However, thinking about the social structure that the elite come from, they risk their family reputation and their own social capital by questioning authority. It's not just what they have worked toward their whole lives, but also what their family has invested in towards their success. 

In 2001, the students that Brooks describes meeting come from an elite background where they are groomed not to question the status quo because it is so advantageous for them. While it can still be difficult to execute, there are quite clearly the steps layed out for them to achieve. There's nothing to need to think about, the path is clearly marked and the resources are available to guide you in the 'right' direction. Just hit the benchmarks that are expected and landing the cushy consulting job can be yours. Marginalized people questioning authority risk a lot more. If a disadvantaged student questions authority or manages to get suspended from college for a year, the economic consequences are much more real. For many, the path to success is not clearly defined. There are fewer resources guiding your choices and path. The marginalized really don't take risks in questioning because they have so much more to lose.

The college admissions and student body within elite universities in 2001 versus 2021 are very different. More colleges and universities are moving in a direction of looking at the whole person in their admissions process, rather than just a checklist of accomplishments and test scores. Some universities such as Harvard even pay for tuition for those who are economically disadvantaged so that there is more of a level playing field and more diverse population represented. During COVID, standardized testing could not be reliably run so many applicants weren't even able to provide test scores. The application process becomes more about who you are as a person rather than how well you can achieve on paper. 

Ultimately, whether you come from an elite background or school or not, as has been discussed in class, there is the feeling in our society that you must portray a 'self made' story to describe your success.  Perhaps the numerous extracurriculars, time spent studying, etc. helps those feel like they've worked their way towards this goal.  

2021 07 26 Leadership vs Celebrity

 07 26 2021  Leadership vs Celebrity

My Magic Sunglasses

"Pseudo events spawn other pseudo events in geometric progression.  This is partly because every type of pseudo-event, being planned, tends to become ritualized, with a protocol and rigidity all its own."  *

[And it Takes Leaders to Disrupt Expectations with Non-Conforming Pseudo-Events?]

 It is simply dazzling to consider the calm exhibited by Kim Kardashian when pressed with questions about her identity-as-work.  I'd say immediately that Kim Kardashian is more than a brand -- way more.  She's an elegant performance artist caught -- in 2011 -- being successful.  Not many performance artists can maintain success for very long at all.  What's impressive is the friendly unwelcome to any serious questions of creating product or playing a game.  I'd say her deflections are masterful and this is a brilliant inventor.

The NYT plays an important character role in the article on authenticity.  For instance, it is supposed to be a knee slapper that Michelle Bachmann uses the word authentic.  Har har -- we already know what this article is going to say.  Turns out Hilary Clinton even claimed authenticity, probably the reason she's a multiple time loser in this writer's mind.  We get some grabbing examples and then a bunch of sentences about what "scholars" have always been telling us about multiple selves and authenticity as a holy grail.  Reagan was seen as authentic!  Who knew that this could be such a contemptible quality.  

And yes, of course, it is not to be touted, because that shows a yearning, a wish stated, that is too authentic.  No one can be authentic, so turn the page or go to the Engagements and Weddings section.  Those people featured have received coaching from the NYT weddings editors on the very best in calculated authenticity.  The couples are coached for months and the stories edited.

I read the Boorstin chapters early in the summer.  It's really spot on.  We are fooled into participating in pseudo events and parallel realities because it seems to be a lot of nice people working assiduously to create what no one is willing to acknowledge as a confectionery bubble.  Surely the latest must-see (press conference, sunglasses line launch) is worth that irreplaceable commodity, human attention. No, we don't need the dancers to spread out for the cameras in the shape of the U.S. Flag (Footlight Parade, https://youtu.be/vlV_Qs-b5Z8?t=143 ) because having seen that scene, we are receptive to earnest performance, and spectacular, revelatory, self-stating moment. Extravagant expectations are our reality.  They are the non-reality we reference when speaking of the status quo.**

Show power and star power: does it invariably transmit through inanimate materials?  When wearing my new Sears sunglasses in 2013, I knew there was magic. Later I realized that the very cool shades were branded Kardashian.

  * Daniel Boorstin, The Image, chapter four. 

**The Image, last of intro and beginning of chapter one.

 

---

 

 

 Prompt questions for Ellen's reference below:

Stephanie Rosenbloom, “Authentic?  Get Real,” New York Times, September 11th, 2011 
1. Does the author suggest that any public figure widely admired for her "authenticity" is actually authentic? If not, why not, and what do you make of it?
2.  What does "calculated authenticity" mean?

Daniel Boorstin, The Image, Chapter 1-2
1. How has our definition of what is newsworthy changed over time? How does that change reflect how we see the world around us?
2. How does Boorstin define pseudo-events? Given that definition, what are some of the pseudo-events that you've witnessed or read about in your own lives?
3. What is the relationship between pseudo-events and the appetite for information? What is the difference between them an propaganda?
4. What is the relationship between pseudo-events and the human pseudo-event?
5. How does Boorstin diagnose the relationship between notions of celebrity and heroism?
 
Kim Kardashian Readings
1. How do you understand the relationship between Kim Kardashian and her brand? Can the two be meaningfully distinguished?
2. Is Kim Kardashian authentic? Authentically what (and how has she cultivated it)?
3. What does our fascination with Kim Kardashian say about us? How does she shape those who are her followers? Do you think she's manipulative or even exploitative?
4. Having read these articles, do you like Kim Kardashian more or less than you did before? Do you respect her more or less than you did before?

Friday, July 23, 2021

7/21 - Leadership and Change

 Change is part of our lives and we need to adapt to every aspect of it. Businesses usually fear change and

 tend to settle for what they already been practicing for many years. People sometimes need to go out of

 their comfort zone and explore new options to become more innovative for a better future of the business.

 The fear of change comes from fearing the unknown and the concern of possible failure which can be

 understandable but we need to take risks in order to become more successful and thrive, which can be a

 better decision than being outdated with a never ending routine. In order for businesses to adopt change

 they have need a leader that has the ability to influence and motivate individuals to embrace and accept

 change for a better future of the business. Leaders should have commitment and passion to lead their 

 teams to success as team members might have doubts and lack of motivation for change. 


The world is changing and so should our way of doing business. Technology is evolving and companies

 are adapting to the new changes we are witnessing recently. Excellent leaders need to motivate and give a

 sense of urgency to their teams that change is necessary and can be crucial to their business future. One of

 the most important skill a leader should definitely possess in order to become a better change maker is 

 empathy. Leaders with empathy tend to understand others and care about their feelings. Showing interest

 in others might help people show more interest in getting out of their comfort zone and have the

 motivation to try change which will be the ultimate push for success within an organization.

 Unfortunately empathy is seen as an underrated soft skill and over looked by many leaders.





Wednesday, July 21, 2021

2021 07 21 Technocratic Solutions to Building Charisma

 

 2021 07 21  Technocratic Solutions to Building Charisma

 

Political Consulting Through the Ages

I am still shaking my head to remember having broken my conviction and looked at Politico or Real Clear Politics in 2018.  It was possible to examine who was being paid by a campaign (the vendor side), what identifiable large groups were giving to a campaign, and which donors were stupid enough to put their name on the list when it seemed everybody else was just giving some other way.  One of the national candidates I had taken note of was clearly -- to my amazement -- supported first and second by 1. University of California and 2. Paul Weiss, NY NY, the well known neighborhood law firm (locations New York, Beijing, Hong Kong, London, San Francisco, Tokyo, Toronto, Washington, D.C., and Wilmington).  This candidate was not running in, and didn't seem to have any obvious connections or issues tied to, either the state of California or New York.  I was mystified that others who may have looked at this same donor page hadn't blown a whistle or something.  But of course, I was probably the only person who even bothered to look or to be confused.  Because that's the way it always is.  It's good to reach out to new friends and let everybody take a stand for [ ? ]

Wasn't clear what the University of California was supporting in this case, or the New York Law Firm.  But with those sums, there was something they wanted they were not getting in their own candidates.

Here's why I am writing this: I have to leave early today so I'm hoping our speaker and John Paul can speak to why off year political spending is expected to be higher for the upcoming midterm election.  Like as high as 2020. 

 https://www.wsj.com/articles/midterm-election-ad-spending-poised-to-soar-as-streaming-tv-attracts-campaigns-11626685200?mod=searchresults_pos13&page=1

 

 


Charisma/ Relationship Building Leads to Money?

There was a moment during the Rebecca Fassio interview that gave me a sense of Deja Vu to the Liar's Poker reading. At a certain point, she mentioned that for her 'it's not all about the money, it is about building a community.' This brought me back to the moment in our book when Michael Lewis mentions that 'it not being about the money is bullshit.' 

Now, I know that Michael Lewis and Rebecca Fassio are in completely different lines of work. And I do not mean for this to imply that Rebecca is lying about her stance on money, but it brought up an interesting tension that I have been contemplating. For Rebecca Fassio, her goal is to build a community to allow money to flow easier. As someone that has been on the end of calls from the university asking for money, I do agree that it requires more relationship building. The times that I have made a donation were determined by the person I was talking to on the phone. If they made the effort to get to know me a little bit, I was willing to donate more money. 

On the other side of the spectrum, Michael Lewis is purely motivated by money. He went to business school to make money. He chose a career that would allow him to make more money. He wrote a whole book that focuses on the pursuit of money. That being said, I can tell by the entertaining writing that Michael Lewis has a strong sense of humor (I haven't finished yet, so no spoilers -- haha). When I look at charismatic leadership, I see people that rise up very quickly. Dale Carnegie's book How to Win Friends and Influence People explains the hot tips for being a great salesperson, and they revolved around relationship building. I also have a co-worker that rose up in status because of his charisma, because if it was based on work merit, he would not have been selected. At least for Michael Lewis, he learned that he might need to convince others that it is not all about the money to succeed. 

I think charisma and the ability to build relationships is a way to get to the top quick. Preferably, it is important to get people to agree to giving money or getting "the job"/ promotion before giving anyone else too much time to think about it. Salespeople survive on this idea. It's a method that I personally do not agree with, but I cannot deny the success and impact it has on the people around me. I just wonder if this kind of leadership is able to last long term? What are the downsides? John Paul mentions that most companies turn to a more technocratic leadership when it becomes much larger. Is it because charisma can only take us so far?

I think with leaders like Rebecca that truly care about the relationship, it thrives longer. I think for people that are motivated purely by money, it is hard to have that genuine appeal. At least in my case, I get turned away by people that are in the latter group. However, it then makes me wonder what we say about con artists? These are people, that are able to mask their true intention. So is everyone mentioned in my post to some extent a con artist? Are we all con artists to some extent? Is that what being a leader is? Or is that too cynical?